Portrait of Rick Porcello

Rick Porcello PRed Sox

Red Sox Player Cards | Red Sox Team Audit | Red Sox Depth Chart

2019 Projections (Preseason PECOTA - seasonal age 30)
138.0 4.10 1.24 123 9 8 0 1.9
Birth Date12-27-1988
Height6' 5"
Weight205 lbs
Age31 years, 3 months, 6 days
WARP Summary

MLB Statistics

Historical (past-seasons) WARP is now based on DRA..
cFIP and DRA are not available on a by-team basis and display as zeroes(0). See TOT line for season totals of these stats.
Multiple stints are are currently shownClick to hide.
2009 DET MLB 31 31 170.7 14 9 0 176 52 89 23 102 9.3 2.7 1.2 4.7 0% .277 1.34 4.81 3.96 106 5.23 112.2 0.6
2010 DET MLB 27 27 162.7 10 12 0 188 38 84 18 112 10.4 2.1 1.0 4.6 0% .307 1.39 4.28 4.92 108 4.99 112.6 0.5
2011 DET MLB 31 31 182.0 14 9 0 210 46 104 18 106 10.4 2.3 0.9 5.1 0% .316 1.41 4.09 4.75 105 4.77 110.8 0.6
2012 DET MLB 31 31 176.3 10 12 0 226 44 107 16 106 11.5 2.2 0.8 5.5 0% .344 1.53 3.86 4.59 107 5.38 123.2 -0.4
2013 DET MLB 32 29 177.0 13 8 0 185 42 142 18 101 9.4 2.1 0.9 7.2 0% .315 1.28 3.55 4.32 94 3.88 93.0 2.3
2014 DET MLB 32 31 204.7 15 13 0 211 41 129 18 105 9.3 1.8 0.8 5.7 0% .298 1.23 3.70 3.43 102 4.42 108.3 1.0
2015 BOS MLB 28 28 172.0 9 15 0 196 38 149 25 115 10.3 2.0 1.3 7.8 0% .332 1.36 4.09 4.92 103 4.57 106.8 1.0
2016 BOS MLB 33 33 223.0 22 4 0 193 32 189 23 114 7.8 1.3 0.9 7.6 44% .269 1.01 3.35 3.15 95 3.37 74.5 5.1
2017 BOS MLB 33 33 203.3 11 17 0 236 48 181 38 104 10.4 2.1 1.7 8.0 40% .322 1.40 4.59 4.65 101 4.84 103.0 1.7
2018 BOS MLB 33 33 191.3 17 7 0 177 48 190 27 106 8.3 2.3 1.3 8.9 45% .285 1.18 4.04 4.28 98 4.02 89.8 2.8
2019 BOS MLB 32 32 174.3 14 12 0 198 45 143 31 108 10.2 2.3 1.6 7.4 39% .308 1.39 4.79 5.52 113 6.06 124.4 -0.5

Statistics for All Levels

'opp' stats - Quality of opponents faced - have been moved and are available only as OPP_QUAL in the Statistics reports now.
Minor league stats are currently shownClick to hide.
2008 LAK A+ FSL 24 24 125.0 8 6 0 116 33 72 7 106 8.4 2.4 0.5 5.2 0% .270 1.19 3.84 2.66 101 4.06 83.1
2009 DET MLB AL 31 31 170.7 14 9 0 176 52 89 23 102 9.3 2.7 1.2 4.7 0% .277 1.34 4.81 3.96 106 5.23 112.2
2010 DET MLB AL 27 27 162.7 10 12 0 188 38 84 18 112 10.4 2.1 1.0 4.6 0% .307 1.39 4.28 4.92 108 4.99 112.6
2010 TOL AAA INT 4 4 28.0 1 2 0 24 10 19 0 99 7.7 3.2 0.0 6.1 0% .296 1.21 3.11 3.21 0 0.00 0.0
2011 DET MLB AL 31 31 182.0 14 9 0 210 46 104 18 106 10.4 2.3 0.9 5.1 0% .316 1.41 4.09 4.75 105 4.77 110.8
2012 DET MLB AL 31 31 176.3 10 12 0 226 44 107 16 106 11.5 2.2 0.8 5.5 0% .344 1.53 3.86 4.59 107 5.38 123.2
2013 DET MLB AL 32 29 177.0 13 8 0 185 42 142 18 101 9.4 2.1 0.9 7.2 0% .315 1.28 3.55 4.32 94 3.88 93.0
2014 DET MLB AL 32 31 204.7 15 13 0 211 41 129 18 105 9.3 1.8 0.8 5.7 0% .298 1.23 3.70 3.43 102 4.42 108.3
2015 BOS MLB AL 28 28 172.0 9 15 0 196 38 149 25 115 10.3 2.0 1.3 7.8 0% .332 1.36 4.09 4.92 103 4.57 106.8
2015 LOW A- NYP 1 1 3.7 0 0 0 3 1 1 0 111 7.4 2.5 0.0 2.5 0% .273 1.09 3.79 0.00 109 4.73 103.7
2015 PAW AAA INT 1 1 5.7 0 0 0 3 0 6 1 79 4.8 0.0 1.6 9.5 0% .167 0.53 3.85 4.76 82 2.78 60.9
2016 BOS MLB AL 33 33 223.0 22 4 0 193 32 189 23 114 7.8 1.3 0.9 7.6 44% .269 1.01 3.35 3.15 95 3.37 74.5
2017 BOS MLB AL 33 33 203.3 11 17 0 236 48 181 38 104 10.4 2.1 1.7 8.0 40% .322 1.40 4.59 4.65 101 4.84 103.0
2018 BOS MLB AL 33 33 191.3 17 7 0 177 48 190 27 106 8.3 2.3 1.3 8.9 45% .285 1.18 4.04 4.28 98 4.02 89.8
2019 BOS MLB AL 32 32 174.3 14 12 0 198 45 143 31 108 10.2 2.3 1.6 7.4 39% .308 1.39 4.79 5.52 113 6.06 124.4

Plate Discipline

YEAR Pits Zone% Swing% Contact% Z-Swing% O-Swing% Z-Contact% O-Contact% SwStr%
2009 2696 0.5115 0.4407 0.8316 0.5925 0.2817 0.8996 0.6819 0.1684
2010 2519 0.5395 0.4371 0.8510 0.5931 0.2543 0.9094 0.6915 0.1490
2011 2855 0.4841 0.4455 0.8404 0.6042 0.2967 0.8994 0.7277 0.1596
2012 2814 0.4755 0.4641 0.8239 0.6061 0.3354 0.9088 0.6848 0.1761
2013 2819 0.4558 0.4519 0.7896 0.6008 0.3272 0.8795 0.6514 0.2104
2014 3036 0.5142 0.4671 0.8223 0.5996 0.3268 0.8942 0.6826 0.1777
2015 2732 0.4927 0.4623 0.7870 0.6367 0.2929 0.8530 0.6478 0.2130
2016 3392 0.5212 0.4788 0.8134 0.6335 0.3103 0.8741 0.6786 0.1866
2017 3359 0.5076 0.4915 0.7880 0.6680 0.3096 0.8332 0.6875 0.2120
2018 3092 0.5100 0.4686 0.7950 0.6392 0.2911 0.8690 0.6259 0.2050
2019 2954 0.5220 0.4892 0.8187 0.6693 0.2925 0.8672 0.6973 0.1813

Injury History  —  No longer being updated

Last Update: 12/31/2014 23:59 ET

Date On Date Off Transaction Days Games Side Body Part Injury Severity Surgery Date Reaggravation
2014-05-13 2014-05-17 DTD 4 3 - Trunk Soreness Ribcage - -
2009-03-17 2009-03-21 Camp 4 0 Right Fingers Laceration Fingernail -


Year Team Salary
2020 NYN $10,000,000
2019 BOS $21,125,000
2018 BOS $21,125,000
2017 BOS $20,125,000
2016 BOS $20,125,000
2015 BOS $12,500,000
2014 DET $8,500,000
2013 DET $5,100,000
2012 DET $3,100,000
2011 DET $1,536,000
2010 DET $1,987,500
2009 DET $2,162,500
2008 DET $1,100,000
12 yrPrevious$118,486,000
13 yrPvs + Cur$128,486,000
13 yrTotal$128,486,000


Service TimeAgentContract Status
10 y 170 dExcel Sports1 year/$10M (2020)

  • 1 year/$10M (2020). Signed by NY Mets as a free agent 12/12/19.
  • 4 years/$82.5M (2016-19). Signed extension with Boston 4/7/15. $0.5M signing bonus. 16:$20M, 17:$20M, 18:$21M, 19:$21M. Limited no-trade protection (may block deals to three clubs).
  • 1 year/$12.5M (2015). Re-signed by Boston 1/16/15 (avoided arbitration).
  • 1 year/$8.5M (2014). Re-signed by Detroit 1/17/14 (avoided arbitration). Acquired by Boston in trade from Detroit 12/11/14.
  • 1 year/$5.1M (2013). Re-signed by Detroit 1/18/13 (avoided arbitration).
  • 1 year/$3.1M (2012). Re-signed by Detroit 1/16/12 (avoided arbitration).
  • 4 years/$7.285M (2007-10), plus 2011-12 club options. Signed Major League contract with Detroit 8/14/07. $3.85M signing bonus. 07:$0.38M, 08:$1.1M, 09:$1.2M, 10:$1.025M, 11:$1.536M club option, 12:$1.344M club option. Optioned to A 3/12/08. Recalled 2009. Optioned to Triple-A 6/20/10. Recalled 7/17/10.
  • Represented by Scott Boras for first pro contract.
  • Drafted by Detroit 2007 (1-27) (Seton Hall Prep, West Orange, N.J.).

2019 Preseason Forecast

Last Update: 1/27/2017 12:35 ET

Weighted Mean?????0.0?00?.0000.000.00?0.00.0

Preseason Long-Term Forecast (Beyond the 2019 Projections)

Playing time estimates are based on performance, not Depth Charts.

Comparable Players (Similarity Index 83)

Rank Score Name Year Run Average Trend
1 93 Don Drysdale 1967 3.22
2 90 Wade Miley 2017 5.95
3 90 Cliff Lee 2009 3.42
4 90 Frank Viola 1990 2.99
5 89 Aaron Harang 2008 5.08
6 89 Gaylord Perry 1969 3.18
7 89 Shaun Marcum 2012 4.14
8 87 Homer Bailey 2016 7.43
9 87 Matt Garza 2014 4.24
10 87 Dick Donovan 1958 3.34
11 87 Jordan Zimmermann 2016 5.38
12 87 Joe Blanton 2011 5.01
13 87 Jon Matlack 1980 4.26
14 87 Mike Mussina 1999 3.90
15 86 Billy Pierce 1957 3.40
16 86 Wei-Yin Chen 2016 5.04
17 86 Jeff Francis 2011 5.02
18 86 Kenta Maeda 2018 4.16
19 86 Billy O'Dell 1963 3.64
20 86 Yovani Gallardo 2016 5.64
21 85 Don Sutton 1975 3.08 DNP
22 85 Nate Robertson 2008 6.62
23 85 Bob Friend 1961 4.54
24 85 Don Newcombe 1956 3.39
25 85 Matt Cain 2015 5.79
26 85 Gil Meche 2009 5.65
27 85 Erik Hanson 1995 4.53
28 85 Javier Vazquez 2007 3.95
29 84 Andrew Cashner 2017 4.05
30 84 Bert Blyleven 1981 2.94
31 84 Carl Pavano 2006 0.00 DNP
32 84 Jeremy Hellickson 2017 5.76
33 84 Jim Bunning 1962 3.91 DNP
34 84 Dick Hughes 1968 3.39
35 84 Gavin Floyd 2013 5.55
36 84 Mike Minor 2018 4.30
37 84 Odalis Perez 2008 4.90
38 84 Jason Hammel 2013 5.23
39 84 Ted Higuera 1988 2.61
40 83 Dave Bush 2010 5.58
41 83 James Shields 2012 4.03
42 83 Bryn Smith 1986 4.85
43 83 Jeff Weaver 2007 6.44
44 83 Sonny Siebert 1967 2.87
45 83 Mark Gubicza 1993 5.26
46 83 Shane Reynolds 1998 3.82
47 82 Larry Jansen 1951 3.31
48 82 Kyle Lohse 2009 5.28
49 82 Kevin Tapani 1994 4.96
50 82 Derek Holland 2017 7.07
51 82 Brad Penny 2008 6.46
52 82 John Lackey 2009 4.29
53 82 Dan Haren 2011 3.44
54 82 Dennis Leonard 1981 3.53
55 82 Doug Drabek 1993 4.09
56 82 Zack Greinke 2014 3.07
57 82 Jon Niese 2017 0.00 DNP
58 82 Fritz Peterson 1972 3.52
59 82 Gil Heredia 1996 6.26
60 81 Kevin Millwood 2005 3.38
61 81 Matt Morris 2005 4.72
62 81 Watty Clark 1932 4.02
63 81 Dwight Gooden 1995 0.00 DNP
64 81 Freddy Garcia 2007 6.05
65 81 Bob Rush 1956 3.46
66 81 Jason Vargas 2013 4.08
67 81 George Uhle 1929 4.46
68 81 Cole Hamels 2014 2.64
69 81 Kevin Correia 2011 5.26
70 81 Travis Wood 2017 7.37
71 81 Ivan Nova 2017 4.62
72 80 Rodrigo Lopez 2006 6.10
73 80 Bob Welch 1987 3.36
74 80 Mickey Lolich 1971 3.18
75 80 Pat Dobson 1972 2.99
76 80 Brett Myers 2011 4.83
77 80 Chase Anderson 2018 4.04
78 80 Paul Maholm 2012 3.81
79 80 Mike Leake 2018 4.75
80 80 Scott Baker 2012 0.00 DNP
81 80 Josh Johnson 2014 0.00 DNP
82 80 Mike Cuellar 1967 3.62
83 80 Ricky Nolasco 2013 4.06
84 80 Jim Kaat 1969 4.23
85 80 Andy Benes 1998 4.32
86 80 Alex Cobb 2018 5.49
87 80 Doug Davis 2006 5.22
88 79 John Smiley 1995 3.67
89 79 Lance Lynn 2017 3.86
90 79 Tommy Milone 2017 8.01
91 79 Alex Fernandez 2000 4.30
92 79 Jerry Koosman 1973 3.18
93 79 Jake Peavy 2011 4.92
94 79 John Candelaria 1984 3.35
95 79 Ray Culp 1972 5.14
96 79 Brian Lawrence 2006 0.00 DNP
97 79 Robin Roberts 1957 4.40
98 79 Edwin Jackson 2014 6.72
99 79 Dave Goltz 1979 4.42
100 79 Chris Tillman 2018 10.80

BP Annual Player Comments

2019  Due to publishing agreements, the 2019 player comments and team essays are only available in the Baseball Prospectus 2019 book (available in hardcopy, and soon e-book and Kindle).
2018 You’ll recall that it was Ben Cherington who brought Porcello to the Red Sox back in 2014. That’s the same Cherington who masterminded teams that finished in last place or won the World Series with no in between. Porcello embodies that type of wild fluctuation. Coming off a season in which he earned the AL Cy Young, Porcello was barely replacement level in 2017. Nothing about who Porcello is changed—there was no velocity drop or shift in repertoire or major injury. He just pitched worse, missing his spots more frequently and suffering from more than his fair share of bad luck. Porcello’s BABIP was well above league average, and while he’s always been a little homer-happy, his 2017 rate was the most extreme of his career. That being said, Porcello’s strategy of getting hitters to chase high fastballs is one that’s prone to producing extreme results—especially with a juiced ball—so it’s hard to say whether he’ll regress to the mean or whether this Jekyll-and-Hyde act is his new norm.
2017 Apparently Porcello read his 2016 Annual comment (set to the tune of TLC’s "Waterfalls") and set out to prove he was No Scrub. One year after his play said “I’m Good At Being Bad,” Porcello won the AL Comeback Player of the Year award and, more notably, the AL Cy Young. You can make a big Whoop De Woo about Justin Verlander or Corey Kluber deserving it more, but Porcello certainly belonged in the conversation. The right-hander set career-best marks in innings pitched, strikeouts, walk rate, ERA and WARP. He challenged hitters to Come Get Some, throwing his fastball higher in the zone than early in his career, but locating it much better than in 2015. As a result, batters couldn’t Get It Up like in years past and Porcello posted a personal-best 9.3 HR/FB percentage. When opponents tried to Creep on base, Porcello wasn’t Damaged; he produced a 3.18 FIP with runners on. And when the ever-vociferous Manny Machado barked at Porcello for hitting him with a Perfect Game going in September, Rick barked back, suggesting Machado was, well, Unpretty. So if you’re reading again, Mr. Porcello, know that while not everyone in the saber community is Diggin’ On You, we also Ain’t 2 Proud 2 Beg to watch you dominate again. Because what you did in 2016 was straight CrazySexyCool.
2016 Ben Cherington had a natural obsession,
for acquiring some groundball SPs.
He gave Rick money for a workload to handle,
but Porcello brought no stability.
One day he started throwing high in the zone,
and it's true he bumped up his strikeout pace.
But hitters teed off and he didn't know why,
took a DL stint for him to save some face.
(Y'all can't cut me.)
Don't go chasing strikeout calls,
just stick to the sinkers and the groundouts you're used to.
I know that the results got better when you pitched in the fall,
but it's hard to look at your stats.
2015 Porcello believers finally saw the season they had been seeking—or, at least, half of it, as the sinker started elevating down the stretch. The AL leader in shutouts—he had never previously thrown even a complete game—finally had a decent infield defense to support his pitch-to-contact tendencies. As his strikeout rate went down, so did his walk rate, and up went his smile rate. He's still young but it's suddenly his last year of arbitration eligibility, which made him available for Boston's winter rotation rebuild.
2014 The if you dont count statistics game is a cheating way to tell a happy story, and yet the game has some merit with Porcello. If he hadnt faced the Angels last year, he would have had a 3.61 ERA in 172 innings. The improvements in his game would have been far more obvious and much more widely noticednobody's impressed by a quarter-run improvement in ERA, but a full run turns some heads. He cut his WHIP dramatically, recorded a career-best 19 percent strikeout rate and even topped his previous best groundball rate. He also allowed 17 runs in five innings to the Angels, including a nine-run, 2/3-inning massacre in late April. Is there any reason not to count starts against the Angels? Of course not. But at least it puts in perspective the relatively small margin between a breakout we notice and a breakout we might miss. With five full seasons of workeach with minor improvements from the lastbefore his 25th birthday, Porcello looks like he might still be a future star.
2013 A 24-year-old with four full seasons of near-league-average work makes Porcello a valuable commodity. But as a highly touted prospect who had his best season in his rookie year and hasnt pitched below a 4.50 ERA since, Porcello gets viewed as something nearing a bust in some circles. Those in the know will tell you he is anything but, and many believe he has multiple levels of untapped potential. Some of that may require the proverbial change of scenery to emerge because Porcello is an elite groundball artist on a team horribly ill-equipped to turn those into outs. This is a major reason why his sabermetric figures are often much better than his ERA. There is still star potential here.
2012 Most any team in baseball would celebrate a 23-year-old starter coming off a 14-win season, one with a three-year track record of good health and success, yet Porcello still struggles against the high expectations that have been pinned to him. He took a few more baby steps forward last year, inching his strikeout rate above five per nine innings, keeping his walk rate low, and generally pitching better than his 4.75 ERA shows. Porcello possesses an effective slider and changeup and can rear back for a mid-90s heater when necessary, but relies heavily on his two-seamer to get copious groundball outsan approach that is more effective than electric, leaving observers wishing for more. Few still see him as a future ace, but Porcello suddenly seems undervalued, He may yet brew up the swing-and-miss elixir that vaults him into the upper ranks of AL hurlers.
2011 Youth provides the opportunity for growth, not a guarantee of it, and entering his third year in the Tigers rotation its hard to measure much growth in Porcello. When drafted, the dream was that he might become Justin Verlander, overpowering batters with an upper-90s fastball. When he proved to be more of a worm-killer in the minors, the ideal became Brandon Webb. Now, after two full seasons with a sub-par strikeout rate, is he really just Jon Garland? Porcello induced the same number of swinging strikes last year as Aaron Cook, and while many point to improvement after his brief mid-season demotion, upping his strikeout rate from 4.22 to 4.97 per nine innings had best be the first step of a journey, not the destination. Ground balls may be more democratic, but Porcello needs to act more like a dictator on the mound or hell become just another mid-rotation journeyman.
2010 Porcello is another in a line of recent, high-draft pitchers whose minor-league numbers are completely useless for analysis. He wasn't pitching as best he could, but was instead working on a specific program designed to develop all of his pitches and teach him to pitch efficiently, and definitely not using the same style of pitching he would use in a major-league game. He relies on a sinking two-seam fastball that reaches 92 mph, and a four-seamer than touches 95, plus a curveball, slider, and change, all with good control. He was a surprise pick to make the team out of spring, but fully deserved itother than a hiccup around the All-Star break, he was solid and consistent. The worry shifts towards keeping his pitch counts and innings in check, as he's only 21.
2009 Porcello was universally seen as one of the top pitching prospects in the game before he threw a pitch as a professional, and in his pro debut he led the Florida State League in ERA as a teenager. Yet, for some reason, his season was categorized by some as a disappointment, mostly due to a low strikeout rate. However, the Tigers limited him by only allowing a small number of breaking balls per start, and also had him focus on his low-90s sinker rather than his monster four-seam fastball. Despite this deliberate pair of handicaps, we repeat: he still led the league in ERA. He's still a future stud, and everyone capable of looking past the numbers knows it.
2008 Rather than let the commissioner's office bonus suggestions dictate their future, the Tigers nabbed the best high school pitcher in the draft all the way down at number 27 and paid far over slot to sign him, committing to a major league deal worth about $7 million. It was the third straight year the Tigers had gone over slot in the first round. Porcello works in the mid-90s, peaking at 98, throws both a slider and curve, and has ace potential.

BP Articles

Click here to see articles tagged with Rick Porcello

BP Chats

2019-12-05 13:00:00 (link to chat)Is either Lugo or Gsellman candidates for the rotation in 2020?
(sportsguy21792 from Madison)
The Mets are sure leaking that they are. I suspect they sign Rick Porcello for that spot though. (New York Mets Top 10 Chat)
2019-08-08 15:00:00 (link to chat)Worse fall from grace: me from episode 1 to episode 2 or Rick Porcello from 2016 to present?
(Blake from Paradise)
So I don't watch the bachelor/ette anymore. I think it's become too self-aware as a franchise and is far too into itself. I also think they need to skew towards older contestants and start with someone outside the current bachelor/ette universe. It's too incestuous. That said, it hasn't been a fall from grace for me because he wasn't on a pedestal before, but I also think what he did wasn't that bad? If he's a single guy? I'll cop to not knowing all the details but I've also heard that a lot of texts came out recently and somewhat vindicated him? There's a lot going on there. Anyway, the answer is Rick Porcello who somehow is having a messier season than Blake. (Craig Goldstein)
2019-07-03 13:00:00 (link to chat)Is Rick Porcello done in terms of fantasy relevancy?
(Jimmi Simpson from Beyond)
Probably? Yeah, I'm going with probably. (Craig Goldstein)
2019-03-15 16:00:00 (link to chat)One opinion I've heard re: starting pitchers is that there is essentially a class of 12-15 guys at the top and then nothing appealing until you start looking at late round flyers. Are there any boring ol' tier two pitchers that you like? (e.g. the David Prices of the world).
(nschaef from NYC)
I'll always be a sucker for Masahiro Tanaka, who seems to go around that range as well. And I'll be interested to see what Chris Archer does with a full season in Pittsburgh. Looking at ADP though, it does look pretty rough for that middle, though. I'll also take Rick Porcello for volume and Tyler Glasnow for Tyler Glasnow-y reasons. (Mark Barry)
2017-07-19 17:00:00 (link to chat)Brett, Thanks for the chat. Rick Porcello or Eduardo Rodriguez, who will have the better over the ROS and next 2 years?
(Stan from Baltimore)
Eduardo Rodriguez, and it wasn't even close. He's far younger, strikes out a ton, and actually projects to improve. (Brett Cowett)
2017-05-02 13:00:00 (link to chat)If you were forced to drop one in a very deep standard league, who would you choose: Odorizzi Manaea Porcello Morton
(Mark from New Hampshire)
Come on, Rick Porcello has been really good this year. The Sox defense hasn't done him any favors. I'm fascinated by Charlie Morton. He's throwing like 96-97 with movement and getting swings and misses consistently. I'd probably cut Odorizzi, but I'm sure you could deal him to another team for something. (George Bissell)
2016-09-15 13:00:00 (link to chat)Why does Rick Porcello get so little love? Is his 2016 season in any way indicative of what we can expect going forward, or can we expect a regression more in line with his 4.32/1.28 from 2013?
(Bob from Fayetteville)
Everyone hates the Red Sox.

2013, you mean that bad year when he had his career best DRA? If I had to pick a year that he'd 'regress towards' it would be 2014, which will be his 3rd best DRA season when this one is over. (Harry Pavlidis)
2016-09-21 13:00:00 (link to chat)What are your thoughts on Rick Porcello and why is Craij wrong?
(Ben from Connecticut)
For reference, Craig and I got into a friendly discussion about his Rick Porcello article, which you should go read here, if you haven't already:

The argument was over how similar Porcello is now to what he was last year, and we got into a bit of a philosophical discussion about command and luck that would be much more fun in an article than over a few tweets. (Brendan Gawlowski)
2016-05-18 19:00:00 (link to chat)Currently running a rotation with Arrieta, Chen, Karns, and pray for rain in a deep league (20 w/ 40 man) 5x5. Can you give me a list of 5 so SP trade targets that you see having value over cost ROS? Thanks...
(Jim from North 40)
Guy who won't break the bank: Rick Porcello, Rich Hill, Drew Pomeranz, J.A. Happ, Matt Andriese just to name a few. (George Bissell)
2016-04-21 19:00:00 (link to chat)Mike ,SP 12 team H2H league w,era.k,whip,k/9. Wire pickups Phelps (Mia),R.Porcello,P.HughesChase Anderson. One or two possible that you may take. Thanks,
(Chesty from New Bern,NC)
I agree with my colleague Bret Sayre that Rick Porcello is the guy to go after. Solid numbers at the end of last year, has built on his success, doing a better job with sequencing once again in 2016. (Mike Gianella)
2015-06-16 20:00:00 (link to chat)If the Red Sox were characters on Game of Thrones, who would they be? thanks
(Bill from Los Angeles)
This is super played out ...

... and as such, right in my wheelhouse.

Xander Bogaerts: Jon Snow
Mookie Betts: Danaerys Targaryen

Ben Cherington: Ned (tried to do the right thing, will probably lose head)
Wade Miley: Catelyn (doesn't do much but yell)
Rick Porcello: Robb Stark (handsome, ineffective)
Clay Buchholz: Sansa (WHAT EVEN ARE YOU?)
Eduardo Rodriguez: Arya (so much potential)
Brock Holt: Bran (takes a lot of forms)
Joe Kelly: Rickon (why do you exist?)
Mike Napoli: Hodor (...yep)
Christian Vazquez: Benjen Stark (plz come back)

John Henry: Tywin (still calling the shots)
Dustin Pedroia: Tyrion (most watchable/resourceful)
Larry Lucchino: Cersei (...)
David Ortiz: Jaime (lost a step but still badass)
Blake Swihart: Tommen (keep trying, little guy)

John Farrell: Stannis (stern but no one seems to listen)
Melisandre: Pablo Sandoval (is your power real or what)
Our Hopes/Dreams: Shireen

Hanley Ramirez: The Hound (unlikeable but powerful)
Koji Uehara: Brienne (still rooting for ya)
Daniel Nava: Pod (you too!)

Junichi Tawawa: Bronn (just gets stuff done)
Allen Craig: Janos Slynt (just doesn't)
Shane Victorino: Jorah (always hurt)
Jackie Bradley: Theon (has he not suffered enough?)
Justin Masterson: Beric Dondarrion (should not have been revived)

Craig Breslow: Doran (smart, ineffective)
Alejandro De Aza: sandsnake 1
Alexi Ogando: sandsnake 2
Tommy Layne: sandsnake 3

The Yankees: Roose Bolton
The Rays: Ramsay Bolton
The Blue Jays: The Night's King
The Orioles: Mance Rayder

And two for the book readers ...
Yoan Moncada: Young Griff
Rusney Castillo: Patchface (Ben Carsley)
2015-04-06 20:15:00 (link to chat)Thanks for the clarification. So now that Porcello is a sandwich, irrevocably, do you think the Sox got a steal? No, but really, talk me through the thought process here. Gonna lock him up till he's 30? We have faith in our GB gameplan? We have to spend the money or the Nation will start asking questions?
(Dylan from CT)
I answered some of this in the first question, but I think ultimately they're paying for age. He's so young and that's going to command some serious coin, but I question whether the typical trappings of youth apply to a guy who's thrown 1073 innings already. Is he more likely to reinvent himself than another pitcher? I don't think so, but I also can't be sure.

I get that putting him in front of a good defense is going to help him a bunch, but I'd be concerned about putting that much money into a guy who misses that few bats, no matter the defense or GB rate, on some level. I do think part of it is that there's just so much money and not that many guys to spend it on, plus bulk innings are worth a lot. I really believe in that last point.

All that being said though, I don't think Rick Porcello is the guy to spend it on. Next year's SP FA class is absolutely monstrous, and there's legitimate ceiling there that I'd rather pay for. I get there's comfort in Porcello, but he offers a lot more downside (sub-100 ERA+) than upside to me, and they paid a bunch for that. (Craig Goldstein)
2015-04-07 14:00:00 (link to chat)Thoughts on the Rick Porcello extension? Seems to be a lot of negative opinions out there, but I think it was a fine deal for Boston to make. If he doesn't improve, it's a slight overpay which they can afford. If he does (and he's only 26 and playing in front of a better defense), could be a nice deal.
(Shawn from CT)
I like the decision to extend him, but I think that $20M per year is a drastic overpay. Even acknowledging that the team is buying out free agent years, I don't see Porcello as being worth anything close to $20M per year from 2016-19. (Doug Thorburn)
2015-03-25 19:00:00 (link to chat)Dynasty rotisserie: which side do you like? Xander Bogaerts and Wilson Ramos or Carlos Gonzalez, Clint Frazier, and Rick Porcello?
(El Ashaban from Queens)
I'll take side two, but I don't want to set a precedent for answering fantasy questions. We have an awesome staff who is more than happy to take those. Use the bat signal. A lot. Seriously, send them 10 questions a day, they'll love it. (Jordan Gorosh)
2015-01-12 13:00:00 (link to chat)Rick Porcello's ERA dropped a full point even though he was striking out 20% fewer batters. Help me make sense of this.
(John from Chicago)
If you look at FIP you'd say he got lucky last season as his FIP in 2013 was 3.53 and in 2014 it was 3.67. He struck out fewer guys but he also walked fewer. He's a very defense-dependent guy given his GB rate and lack of Ks so pitching in Detroit wasn't an ideal set up for him. Boston should be better, but I'm not sure he's much better than he was last season. A three win pitcher is probably about right for him unless his K rate goes way up, which at this point seems unlikely. (Matthew Kory)
2014-11-18 13:00:00 (link to chat)I am having a tough time reading Rick Porcello's year. On one hand he is only 26 and coming off big improvements in ERA and ERA+. On the other hand, he has had six full seasons where he is averaging 5.5 k/9. Was 2014 real improvement or an outlier, and should we expect a league average pitcher going forward or for him to build on those improvements?
(John from Chicago)
I think there is some legitimacy to the improvement, John, but don't see Porcello ever emerging as a frontline arm. He's a very solid pitcher in spite of the low strikeout rate, and I'd expect around a 3.75 ERA, splitting the difference between his past two years, but leaning toward 2014 as the Tigers continue to improve defensively with the addition of Gose. He's better than league average (which I'd put around a fourth starter), and more of a middle-to-low-end no. 3 starter for me. (Daniel Rathman)
2014-10-14 18:00:00 (link to chat)What's your take on Rick Porcello's season? Is he a top 20 pitcher going forward? Is the low ERA still likely with less than 6 k/9?
(Perry from Detroit)
Top 20, no. But he's been such a lightning rod of criticism in the Tigers community for Not Being Justin Verlander, and now he had the year Verlander wished he'd had. It all fell into place and jeez he'll still be just 26 next year. I think he can get better. (Matt Sussman)
2014-08-25 13:00:00 (link to chat)What do you think of Rick Porcello's value over the next few years?
(Rick from Detroit)
He's starting to look like a solid #2 arm. A high teens earnings peak is not unreasonable, with the possibility that he exceeds that once or maybe twice. (Mike Gianella)
2014-08-21 13:00:00 (link to chat)Is this the real Rick Porcello? Do you think he can pitch at this level for the next few years?
(Ja from Columbus)
I think this is real, he's an example of a young guy who matured on a big league mound. It happens and I think he's going to stick around with his command/sinker/cutter profile. (Harry Pavlidis)
2014-07-08 13:00:00 (link to chat)What kind of prospect package would a pitcher like Rick Porcello net the tigers in a trade today?
(Rick from Detroit)
I've been driving the train that says Porcello is criminally underrated by Tigers fans for the last few years. He's not flashy and he has not reached the lofty expectations established for him during his minor league career, but he is a quality arm that logs plenty of innings and typically performs to a roughly league average level. That is an incredibly valuable asset.

That said, that asset is incredibly valuable to the team that posseses him, not necessarily on the trade market at mid-season. I think the Tigers could get a solid package for him, but nothing overwhelming and certainly nothing that would necessitate them dropping everything to work out the deal tomorrow. (Mark Anderson)
2014-05-21 13:00:00 (link to chat)How are you valuing Rick Porcello in dynasty leagues moving forward? Is this a break out year and is more improvement to be expected in the next couple seasons? Thanks!
(Steve from Los Angeles)
I've long believed that he has frontline capability (more of a #2/#3 than an ace). I think we will continue to see him evolve and incrementally develop into a stud. (Paul Sporer)
2014-03-27 13:00:00 (link to chat)Do you think Rick Porcello takes another step forward this year?
(Dave from Boston)
I still believe. Yes. (R.J. Anderson)
2014-02-20 13:00:00 (link to chat)Will Rick Porcello follow up on his successful season with a major breakout.
(Big Jim from Gators Creek, Georgia)
I think so, yes. The revamped IF defense of Detroit is going to be huge for him (Paul Sporer)
2014-02-20 13:00:00 (link to chat)Do you have a favorite sleeper project who you predict will breakout this year?
(Rick from Cleveland)
Really high on AJ Griffin & Rick Porcello. The former has the stuff to curb those HRs and really surge. The latter has star-potential and now an IF defense to turn his elite GB into many outs (Paul Sporer)
2014-02-10 13:00:00 (link to chat)What could the tigers get for Rick Porcello in a trade? 1 top 100 prospect and more?
(Jason from Ohio)
Considering they didn't get one for Doug Fister, I doubt it. (Jeff Moore)
2014-01-02 13:00:00 (link to chat)Who has the best chance to increase their K% and their Swinging Strike % in the upcoming year?Can you rank them? Dan Straily, Jarrod Parker, Ivan Nova, Kris Medlen, Garrett Richards, Dillon Gee, and finally Rick Porcello.
(allangustafson from Fun Diego )
I'll rank based on who I like the most, as I'm not sure on the potential % increases in either category: Parker, Nova, Medlen, Gee, Porcello, Richards. I think Parker is the clear #1 in this grouping, and I'm a big fan of Nova in 2014. (Craig Goldstein)
2013-12-10 18:00:00 (link to chat)I was lucky enough to hit on all of Ryu, Colon, Porcello, and Kazmir last year. Would you rank them in that order for 2014? (18 team league, points roughly akin to linear weights, wins essentially not important.)
(justarobert from Santa Clara)
Hi Justarobert (if that is your real name!)

I would probably rank them Ryu, Colon, Kazmir and Porcello. I know some people are really high on Rick Porcello and point to his 2 horrific outings as killing his stats, but I'm just not a big believer. I think he'll be OK mind you, but I like Scott Kazmir's upside, particularly in that park. Depending on where Bartolo Colon lands, I might even put Kazmir ahead of Colon. (Mike Gianella)
2013-11-14 13:00:00 (link to chat)Are there any players who you had seen multiple times and felt you had a great read on either good or bad, then completely surprised you by going in the opposite direction?
(petelunchbox from Handsome City)
This happens all the time. It is an unfortunate side effect of the business we are in. I was locked down, convinced Rick Porcello was a future #2 starter. I saw Marcus Stroman repeatedly in college and was convinced beyond a shadow of a doubt that he wouldn't last as a starter in the minor leagues. Like I happens a lot, and I'm not ashamed to admit when it does. (Mark Anderson)
2013-10-17 13:00:00 (link to chat)Harry, Would like your take on the upside of Rick Porcello going forward?
(vampires from michigan)
mid-rotation guy. I think his improvements in getting more strike outs and ground outs could be lasting. He made a change (more curves, fewer sliders) that may give this year's performance a little more weight than normal, relative to the recent past. If he's not with Detroit, he could fetch something nice in a trade. Think of him like Edwin Jackson, although a very different style. He'll eat a ton of innings, occasionally look awesome, sometimes awful, but mostly alright. (Harry Pavlidis)
2013-06-20 13:00:00 (link to chat)Gerrit Cole or Rick Porcello? 12 team mixed 5x5 league.
(jrcolwell from Minneapolis)
That's really tough, especially since we haven't seen the Ks from Cole yet. I'd lean Cole for the upside, park, and league. If he doesn't work out, there'll likely be a Porcello-esque asset available on the wire to replace him. I've always been a Porcello fan and remain a huge one, but Cole has legit #1 upside and while it's unlikely to come this year, it could. (Paul Sporer)
2013-06-04 13:00:00 (link to chat)Agree or Diasgree- Rick Porcello seems to have turned a corner. And if he has, that Detroit rotation is just unfair...
(Shawn from Client's Conference Room)
He has for these last few starts, but we have to see it more consistently to say he's DEFINITELY turned the corner. (Paul Sporer)
2013-04-12 14:00:00 (link to chat)There was a lot of "blah blah blah" about Rick Porcello this spring (out with slider, in with curve, lots of K's, etc.), but the results look pretty familiar to the untrained eye. Has your trained eye had a chance to see him? Any reason for optimism?
(Jim H from Sphinx Park, CO)
Lots of Porcello questions. His hype is fueled by his rare combination of youth + experience, along with an overall trend of increasing velocity that inspires optimism. But the velo this season is still short of previously established levels, and the early returns look similar to the past. I am optimistic, but realistically I will have him on my fantasy bench until I see concrete evidence of improvement.

On the jukebox: Long Beach Dub All Stars, "Rosarito" (Doug Thorburn)
2013-03-20 11:00:00 (link to chat)in a 20teams 5SP slots league where QS is a factor, am I shaky going into season w/ Homer Bailey, Matt Harvey, Kris Medlen, Andy Pettitte and Rick Porcello as rotation?
(Jim from Seattle)
Yes. (Cory Schwartz)
2013-01-29 14:00:00 (link to chat)where is Rick Porcello headed and for whom?
(tweezer from utah)
It's hard to say at this point, tweezer, but we seem to get at least a couple of rumors involving Porcello every week. I do think he'll be traded, but could only speculate about the destination. To mention a couple of teams, the Mariners and Padres might make sense. (Daniel Rathman)
2013-01-16 13:30:00 (link to chat)Why the hurry to trade Rick Porcello? Wouldn't they be better off keeping him in the 5 hole of the rotation and Smyly in Toledo until the inevitable injury? Failing that, what is little Ricky worth in prospects?
(DetroitDale from Florida (eternal spring training))
I don't see the rush to trade Porcello, personally. I think he's worth more to the Tigers on the roster than he is in trade. If the Tigers are overwhelmed by an offer, then I think it makes sense to move him. Otherwise, it makes sense for the Tigers to hold onto him seeing as they have precious little depth at starting pitcher. (Mark Anderson)
2012-12-18 13:00:00 (link to chat)Is Rick Porcello the breakout candidate that his upwardly trending peripherals suggest that he is? And is Detroit really willing to move him for an RP?
(Xolo from Sudamerica)
Yes and no. Or at least I desperately the latter is a no. I saw the Porcello/Hanrahan stuff being floated and never really bought it. The Porcello/Bourjos talk is much more viable (and as a Tigers fan, I'd LOVE it).

I'm a big fan of Porcello and think he has has star potential, though not with this infield defense behind him. It just doesn't suit his game so they might as well parlay him for a big return. (Paul Sporer)
2012-02-13 13:00:00 (link to chat)What is Jacob Turner's ceiling.......a poor man's Justin Verlander or a rich man's Rick Porcello?
(Rooney from King of Prussa)
He's actually not like either of this pitchers. (Kevin Goldstein)
2011-12-14 13:00:00 (link to chat)In your opinion, do you think Jacob Turner is the real deal, or Rick Porcello 2.0?
(Anello from Chicago)
Rick Porcello 2.0 isn't exactly a bad thing, but I get the point. I think Turner's the real deal. (Jason Parks)
2011-09-02 14:00:00 (link to chat)Would Rick Porcello, at age 22, fall into the same category that you just put Jeremy Hellickson in? I.E. with his stuff he needs time to learn, even after 3 seasons? Thanks.
(lemppi from Iowa)
That's a fascinating way to look at things, and while I'm not totally convinced, I think it's possible to think you are onto something. (Kevin Goldstein)
2011-06-14 13:00:00 (link to chat)Just recently made a trade in one of my fantasy leagues. I get Mark Melancon and Brandon Lyon, but I give up Rick Porcello. I plan to have Melancon and Lyon replace Matt Guerrier and Phil Coke, and I will replace Porcello with James McDonald. Thoughts?
(Big Bob from Cleveland)
My first thought is that the Yankees might like to have Melancon right about now. Sounds like a plan to me, though I know the fantasy cognoscenti always say it's easy to find saves. (Ben Lindbergh)
2010-12-20 13:00:00 (link to chat)Cahill put up some gaudy stats last season, but his peripherals weren't strong. I think he had 118 Ks. How does he become a true front-line starter instead of a guy who performs well because of the stadium he pitches in?
(Tom from Madison)
WAYYYY too early to tell. Some pitchers are able to succeed in spite of poorer peripherals. Others aren't. It's easy to think that poor peripherals means he will be less effective next season, but very rarely do people consider that he could improve those peripherals. Rick Porcello hasn't. Maybe Cahill will. (Eric Seidman)
2010-12-14 13:00:00 (link to chat)How Concerned should Tigers fans be about Rick Porcello's drop in K's last year? He's probably not the next Justin Vernlander after all, but is he the next Jeremy Bonderman?
(DetroitDale from Tallahassee, FL)
He ought to be more durable, but Porcello has to prove he's more than a one-trick pony, otherwise nobody's going to be swinging and missing. A great sinker is a thing of beauty, but if everyone knows it's coming... (Christina Kahrl)
2010-12-02 13:00:00 (link to chat)A half decade from today, who's had the better 5 seasons? Zach Greinke, or Rick Porcello?
(singledigit from San Diego)
This is the sort of question that might very well come back to haunt someone, especially given the possibility of injury. Right now, though, I'd say Greinke, and it's not particularly close. I'm really worried about Porcello's inability to miss bats, and while the groundballs are nice, he needs to strike more guys out to be much more than a third starter. He struck out more after his stint in the minors last year, but not enough to allay my concerns unless it was the first step of a major trend. (Ken Funck)
2010-11-11 13:00:00 (link to chat)By the time they both hit about 32-yrs old....who has had the better career, Max Scherzer or Rick Porcello?
(lemppi from Ankeny, IA)
Scherzer. He's already shown that he can strike out major league hitters, and that is the best predictor of future success. There's no doubt that Porcello has crazy upside but he's not getting whiffs yet, and so I have to play the odds and say Scherzer. (Matt Swartz)
2010-11-02 13:00:00 (link to chat)Rick Porcello -- can he become a third ace in the Tigers rotation, or does the last two years lower his ceiling somewhat?
(Jim Osterberg from Detroit Rock City)
I have to be careful here. I was once assaulted with a barrage of mean-spirited questions when I said that I thought Kershaw would become an ace and Porcello would disappoint about two years ago I think. In short, no, I don't think he will become a third ace. I think he could be a really good #4-type pitcher with his current repertoire and "stuff" but he doesn't strike anyone out, and I haven't seen enough to indicate that is going to change moving forward. This doesn't mean I think he is bad, or that he couldn't become better, but that I still just do not see it yet. The same thing happened with Gavin Floyd, though, who looked a bit lost before turning it on. Maybe Porcello follows a similar path. (Eric Seidman)
2010-09-21 13:00:00 (link to chat)Did Rick Porcello's career effectively end as a potential ace last year when he was worked like a rented mule?
(RhubarbOrDeath from Portland)
I think his decision to stick with this two-seamer is holding him back a lot more than that. (Marc Normandin)
2010-06-07 18:30:00 (link to chat)Rank these big name, big time HS Righthand Pitchers: Josh Beckett, Rick Porcello, Gerrit Cole, Jameson Taillon.
(Cult of Basebaal from Pasadena of Los Angeles)
Beckett, Taillon, Porcello, Cole. Love them all. (Kevin Goldstein)
2010-05-05 13:00:00 (link to chat)What do you do with young Tigers' pitcher Max Scherzer and Rick Porcello going forward?
(nschaef from CT)
I wasn't high on Porcello this year to begin with, though I don't mean he doesn't have a bright future. I just mean that I figured there would be some struggles this year (for reference, when asked about this before, I felt Brett Anderson was much further along in his development). He's going to be great, but I don't think that word applies to 2010.

Scherzer's velocity seems to be down a bit, but it's early so I'm having a hard time getting too worked up about it. I'm sticking with him in my AL-only league (though I may have to deal him for an outfielder given my previously referenced situation. Le sigh). (Marc Normandin)
2010-01-21 13:00:00 (link to chat)My last slot in a deep keeper league looks like it's coming down to Dexter Fowler and Rick Porcello. I usually prefer the position player, but Porcello could be special. At the same time, both might have another year or two of development before they really get going. Preference for 2010? Long-term?
(Rob from Alaska)
I would normally prefer the position player too, but Porcello's last two months were pretty impressive. I just wish his strikeouts would jump up, but it will happen with time. He could be a beast in the second half of 2010... (Marc Normandin)
2010-01-13 13:00:00 (link to chat)Who is the better bet for a long and effective career?: Rick Porcello, Brett Anderson or Tommy Hanson.
(Scott from New Jersey)
Tommy Hanson. I really think he has dominant, No. 1-ace stuff, though Porcello and Anderson both have good chances of enjoying outstanding careers, too. (John Perrotto)
2009-12-29 15:00:00 (link to chat)Thanks for the chat. Here's the order in which I rank the following young SPs in projected career value - Tommy Hanson, Rick Porcello, Brett Anderson, Neftali Feliz, Chris Tillman, Mat Latos, Madson Bumgarner. I realize that guessing at career value for young SPs is a crapshoot but do you violently disagree with any aspect of this order?
(KerryFam4 from Atlanta, GA)
I'd have Feliz higher, and I'm not totally convinced the last two belong in this discussion. Porcello might be best, too. (Joe Sheehan)
2009-10-23 16:00:00 (link to chat)Did Porcello start in Minny impress u-I know u think he is chopped liver compared to Brett.
(JOESAV from ny)
Let me try and put an end to this. I don't dislike Rick Porcello. At all. There is a definitive middle ground between thinking someone will be a star and thinking someone will be a bust. I personally think Porcello is and will be a very good major league pitcher but I just did not get the same feeling watching him that I did watching Kershaw last year or Anderson this year. That doesn't mean I dislike him. I'm just not as high on him as others and not convinced that he is going to turn into a perennial all star or Cy Young Award candidate. That's it. End of story. If I'm wrong, I'm wrong, but I don't have anything against the guy. (Eric Seidman)
2009-10-13 14:00:00 (link to chat)I asked Kevin and he demured, I'll try you: Rick Porcello or Tommy Hanson?
(SC from Minneapolis)
Kevin's wise to demur; I'm not, so I'll go with Hanson, having already tipped my hand here. (Christina Kahrl)
2009-10-06 13:30:00 (link to chat)Tigers fan here. Talk me down from the ledge... please?
(David from Winston Salem)
I'd love to but I can't do it in good faith. I think it's going to be awfully hard to win in the Metrodome, though I did have a chance to visit with Rick Porcello earlier this year and came away very impressed with the poise and maturity he shows for such a young guy. (John Perrotto)
2009-10-06 13:30:00 (link to chat)Your pick for today? Your 4 picks in this round? I'm going to say Twins then Yanks, Angels, Cardinals, and Rockies.
(GrinnellSteve from Iowa)
I'm going against all logic and laws of momentum today and picking the Tigers. I have a lot of faith in Rick Porcello. As far as my first-round picks, I'll go Yankees, Red Sox, Rockies and Dodgers. (John Perrotto)
2009-09-02 13:00:00 (link to chat)porcello walks too many? and joba doesn't? you can really make a straight faced arguement that joba is a better pitcher right now? just looked at the numbers, and the 20 year old kid looks better
(ct tiger from ct)
Rick Porcello is currently striking out 4.97 batter per nine innings, a rate that Paul Byrd would even laugh at. Walking 2.94 per nine is nice, but not by comparison to the strikeout rates. He has a 56% GB rate meaning he is very dependent on the team's defense. Joba is not in the same boat, and I feel that it is more likely Joba decreases his walks than Porcello increases the whiffs. (Eric Seidman)
2009-07-13 14:00:00 (link to chat)Most believe the Tigers need a bat. Does one bat solve enough of their issues? Or does getting a rotation piece help fortify the formula of pitching/defense that has worked so far? Thanks.
(lemppi from Ankeny, IA)
That may depend on what they can get from Rick Porcello the rest of the way. Do they have three starters now or two? And is last year's Armando Galarraga anywhere to be found? On the flip side, how much would a healthy Carlos Guillen change the mix? Finally, what do they have to trade? Throw it all in a hat, and I think they'll be pretty quiet. (Joe Sheehan)
2009-05-12 13:00:00 (link to chat)Are you in the camp of "Make Joba a reliever" or "Keep him as a starter"? It seems that right now, he's just not making it through five innings with out a lot of unnecessary difficulty.
(Tim from Tampa, FL)
Then again, he's leading Yankees starters in ERA. There is some difficulty right now, but until he shows he can't worth through it, he's a starter. Besides, with Hughes in the majors, Wang wounded, and Ian Kennedy having an aneurysm cut out of his armpit, who should take over for Joba? Red Ruffing?

Sometimes, just to tease me, when I say to my wife, "Matt Scherzer had a good start tonight" or Rick Porcello, or Chad Billingsley, she'll say, "But he'd be more valuable in the bullpen." I have a great wife. Only people who truly love you care enough to give you that kind of grief. (Steven Goldman)
2009-02-16 14:00:00 (link to chat)Question 1: In conclusion, Kevin, which system more closely resembles the Great dust bowl: The Astros or the Tigers? Question 2: What has Engel Beltre shown to merit inclusion on the list that you haven't seen from Martin Perez?
(Or from Dallas)
1. At least the Tigers have a shining oasis in Rick Porcello. 2. Utterly ridiculous tools. (Kevin Goldstein)
2008-10-09 14:00:00 (link to chat)So which prospect SPs take the place of Price, Kershaw, etc. as the next big thing?
(Jake from Dallas)
Well, I don't think we're done seeing if those guys get over the hump yet, particularly considering Price has just 14 innings under his belt.

IANKG (I am not Kevin Goldstein) but looking over his Top 100 update from earlier in the summer, Rick Porcello (Detroit), Neftali Feliz (Texas) and Chris Tillman (Baltimore) look like the highly-ranked guys who moved up without losing eligibility. Beyond that, I'm out of my league. (Jay Jaffe)
2008-06-04 16:00:00 (link to chat)Without even throwing a pitch, you had both David Price and Rick Porcello in the top 12 prospects in all of baseball. Do you see any of this years' draft picks making it into the top 10 in similar fashion?
(ericmilburn from San Francisco)
Actually, no. (Kevin Goldstein)
2008-03-03 13:00:00 (link to chat)Kevin, Based on your comments in today's Monday Ten Pack, does your gut tell you that Rick Porcello will outrank David Price on next year's prospect list?
(DB from New York)
Not especially. I mean it wouldn't shock me if he did, but you're looking at the opinion of one scout, and you are talking about two guys who are among the elite arms in the minors, so it's hard to see why one of them is going to suddenly drop. (Kevin Goldstein)

BP Roundtables

DateRoundtable NameComment
2009-06-09 14:30:002009 Draft CoverageBaltimore eyed young pitching all along, but in the end, they decided that the top guys weren't worth the coin as they take Matt Hobgood, A guy most people saw as a mid-to-late first round kind of talent.

If you see the video on MLB, you can see why conditioning could end up an issue. MLB people talking about how he moved up, but there's only one reason -- when teams called him, he didn't mention the name Rick Porcello. (Kevin Goldstein)

PITCHf/x Pitcher Profile

A Collaboration between and Baseball Prospectus - Pitch classifications provided by Pitch Info LLC