|2017-06-13 12:00:00 (link to chat)||In February 2016, I was debating between Bradley Zimmer and Aaron Judge in a prospect draft. I went Zimmer.
A few months later, I was feeling great, thinking it was becoming clear I made the right choice.
This past offseason, Zimmer got exposed with his Ks.
And now, I realized I passed up on a 40 HR hitter.
All this to say prospects are fickle, man. |
(Sam from Arizona)
|Indeed. Of course Judge was exposed in the majors with his strikeout issue and now look at him (no, I'm not predicting an insane rebound for Zimmer). These things happen, and it is important to remember that neither of these guys are set in stone as they are now. They're going to be different guys over the next few years. Remember when Randal Grichuk was the next superstar in 2015? He got optioned to High-A this year. Things change. (Craig Goldstein)|
|2016-09-23 12:30:00 (link to chat)||I would love to see this discussed further in an article or on the podcast but for once I'm actually sitting down to write this.
I know in your book Ben and you lamented about how you provided all this data to your players with the hopes they would use it to their benefit and to your knowledge no one really did. Last month Derrick Goold wrote a column about Brandon Moss prepare to provide Randal Grichuk with some analytic data about his performance before a demotion. Baseball analytics have seemed to infiltrated the front office to analyze players worth but is there any evidence of this data being used to help develop or improve their players? Do you think things like this is what separates a major leaguer from a minor/independent league player?|
(Brenden from Raleigh, NC)
|I think analytic data is being used well in player development. But the truth is that most of us aren't great at incorporating performance data into our lives. I, for instance, have access to performance data on my writing--traffic, for every article I've ever written. Do I use it to become a better writer? Nope! It's hard to blame players for having a lot on their mind. (Sam Miller)|
|2016-01-14 20:00:00 (link to chat)||What do you make of Randal Grichuk? WIll he be able to make enough contact to stay in the lineup and let his power play?|
(Kingpin from Grinnell, IA)
|I'm a fan of Grichuk's so I'm a little biased, but I think he will make enough contact to survive as an everyday player and perhaps be a regular 20-25 home run guy. That batting average from last year isn't going to hold, though. (Mike Gianella)|
|2015-07-23 17:00:00 (link to chat)||Can Randal Grichuk be a .260 30 HR hitter? He is hitting the ball very hard according to the batted ball data|
(NightmareRec0n from Boston)
|That's too much on the power. I think 20 is a more realistic ceiling, maybe 25 if everything broke right in a given year. (Mike Gianella)|
|2015-06-02 18:00:00 (link to chat)||You and Mike Matheny switch roles, so that you fill out the major-league roster (and he does commentary, if anyone notices). Who gets the playing time with that crowded outfield situation? Holliday is obviously near 100%, but how do you apportion the rest between Jon Jay, Jason Heyward, Peter Bourjos and Randal Grichuk?|
(Bill from New Mexico)
|I'm completely compromised when it comes to Peter Bourjos. I'd go Grichuck, Bourjos and Heyward LF/CF/RF with Jay filling in the corners and never ever setting foot in center again. (Mauricio Rubio)|
|2015-01-05 15:00:00 (link to chat)||Which of these K machines do you have high hopes for or do you see them all flaming out? Domingo Santana, Jake Lamb, Randal Grichuk, Steven Moya, Yorman Rodriguez. Will any of these guys have long careers as starters? Which has the highest upside and who will flame out? |
(ColeWhittier from Pasadena, CA)
|I can't say that I have high hopes for any of them because of the aforementioned strike out issues, but Lamb's are perhaps the most under control and he should be able to pop enough mistakes out of the park for third base. At least with a guy like Santana, he draws some walks to go with the strike outs. Can't say the same about Moya. Not sure that any of them end up being regulars for any extended period of time. (Jeff Moore)|
|2014-10-09 15:00:00 (link to chat)||Shocked by how much the Cards are using Randal Grichuk in the playoffs. Do you peg him as an everyday contributor in the near future? Power upside?|
(Jim Mora from Crankytown)
|I'm also relatively surprised. I think he's probably a 45/50 OFP guy. I do believe that he's going to hit for some power, but the approach needs some seasoning, and it's awful hard to give that many PA's to a guy who OBPs in the .300 range. (Jordan Gorosh)|
|2014-09-25 13:00:00 (link to chat)||Thanks Graig I pulled the trigger on the Myers for DeGrom trade. Which outfielder do you see producing more
Randal Grichuk or Ender Inciarte next yearin a 12 team league they are at best back ups this year.|
(OB1KENOBI from Tampa)
|I guess I'd go with Grichuk there, but owning either in a 12-team league makes me nauseous. (Craig Goldstein)|
|2013-11-25 13:00:00 (link to chat)||Randal Grichuk:
1. How many Randal Grichuk questions do you expect to get?
2. Is he even worth someone talking about?|
(Max from Springfield)
|I've received a lot. He will play in the majors, most likely developing into a below-average major league regular. He can beat your mistakes and can handle a corner spot, so he's not without value. It's just not anything to get worked up about. (Jason Parks)|
|2013-09-11 13:00:00 (link to chat)||Was the Hickory team for the Rangers the most star studded prospect team in recent memlryr|
(Mark from Charlotte )
|Give me the 2010 Cedar Rapids Kernels. Mike Trout, Pat Corbin, Tyler Skaggs, Johnny Hellweg, Garrett Richards, Ariel Pena, Fabio Martinez, Jean Segura, Randal Grichuk. Man, the Angles traded almost every single one of those guys away. And you wonder why their farm system is barren right now. (Jason Cole)|
|2011-06-02 13:00:00 (link to chat)||Welcome to BP!
Would really love to hear more about how you got into Scout School and some tales of how it went. Could you possibly write an article on this?
(SaberTJ from Cleveland, OH)
|Thanks! I'm very excited to be here. Unfortunately, if I recall correctly, they didn't want me to write too much about the inner workings of the program, so an article would probably be out of the question. I can tell you that I remember Billy Hamilton (Reds), Francisco Peguero (Giants), and Chris Withrow (Dodgers) being some of the more impressive guys I saw and thinking all three could be legit big-leaguers. I was kind of unimpressed with the small sample I saw of Randal Grichuk. Also, on the last day, there were some Arizona Fall Leaguers taking BP on the field across from where we were, and I remember watching Jason Heyward and thinking that he had awesome bat speed. At this point I don't need to tell you that Heyward is good, but given his slow (potentially injury-compromised) start to 2011 and now his DL stint, he might be a good guy to inquire on in fantasy leagues. (Derek Carty)|