CSS Button No Image Css3Menu.com

Baseball Prospectus home
Click here to log in Click here to subscribe
No Previous Article
<< Previous Column
Transaction Analysis: ... (03/24)
Next Column >>
Transaction Analysis: ... (04/17)
No Next Article

April 3, 2000

Transaction Analysis

March 23-31, 2000

by Christina Kahrl

(Ed. note: Chris is on vacation this week. TA will resume, with a twice-a-week schedule, on April 11.)


Acquired RHP Kent Bottenfield and 2B Adam Kennedy from the Cardinals in exchange for CF Jim Edmonds. [3/23]

Assigned RHPs Brett Hinchliffe, Greg Keagle, Steve Mintz and 2B Keith Luuloa to their minor-league camp; optioned C Bret Hemphill to Edmonton. [3/25]

Optioned 1B Larry Barnes, 2B Trent Durrington and RHP Brian Cooper to Edmonton; assigned C Steve Decker and RHP Eric Weaver to their minor-league camp. [3/28]

Optioned LHP Mike Holtz to Edmonton; placed LHP Jarrod Washburn on the 15-day DL, retroactive to 3/25 (strained oblique); acquired OF Edgard Clemente and a PTBNL from the Rockies for C Jason Dewey and OF Norm Hutchins; released DH Todd Greene. [3/29]

There's a certain sadness here, one even a Mouse-hater or a disinterested party can appreciate. The Angels' lone option for improving via trade was dealing either Jim Edmonds or Garret Anderson, and Bill Stoneman managed to screw it up. The long-rumored possibility of getting Adam Piatt or Mario Encarnacion and a pitcher or two from the Athletics? Gone. Getting Brett Tomko from the Mariners? Gone. It may not be fair to hold Stoneman up to his own expectations from a couple of months ago. He was never going to get a deal for as many prospects as he wanted, settling for one of baseball's better utility pitchers and a solid second-base prospect.

While that's what a one-year rental for Edmonds would be worth in a league filled with great GMs, Adam Kennedy is going to have to be awfully good to live up to what was hoped for. There's an impression that Kennedy wasn't very good last year, but it was only his second full season using wood bats. While some people think he can play second base well enough, its far from unanimous. The best news is that he's a better player than Andy Sheets. The bad news is that he's a similar offensive player to Anderson, which is great if you want singles and low OBPs. It makes for a good roto team.

Other issues have come to a head: the team is stuck with the momentous choice between Scott Schoenweis and Kent Mercker for the fifth starter's job. Mike Scioscia's education as a manager in the American League is going to involve a first rude lesson when he sorts out that a DH platoon of Scott Spiezio and Edgard Clemente isn't that much better than having Orel Hershiser bat.


Released RHP Brad Clontz. [3/30]

Which only raises the issue of why they nabbed him in the first place, but there's nothing wrong with multiple redundancies. If Byung-Hyun Kim flopped in camp and Mike Morgan had to start, maybe they would have used him. There are still a thousand better apples that might fall from the tree, but if you really have to have a sidearmer....


Optioned C Pascual Matos to Richmond. [3/25]

Signed RHP Greg McMichael to a minor-league contract. [3/26]

Signed RHP John Burkett; waived 1B Randall Simon and RHP Rafael Medina. [3/29]

Released SS Ozzie Guillen. [3/31]

On the pitching side of things, the Braves seem to be trying to out-old the Mets, not exactly a worthy goal. If they do wuss out and decide to keep Bruce Chen out of the rotation, they might still give him a good middle-relief learning experience, like Kevin McGlinchy last year. But picking up Greg McMichael and talking about how excited they are to have him isn't a good sign for that scenario. They also seem to be going out of their way to let Bobby Bonilla crack the squad.

It would be easy to blame all of this on John Schuerholz, given that this is exactly the sort of veteran-happy artery clogging he pulled off in Kansas City while running the Royals into the ground. This sort of risk-averse roster management, where known mediocrities get first cut at the roster, is only going to give Mets fans cause for hope.

Conspiracy theorists will note that the two teammates John Rocker trashed have been dumped. While Randall Simon has some value as a pinch-hitter, the Ozzeroo is about four years removed from a point when he might have been useful. There's something wrong with sportswriting today when Guillen's postseason gaffe of 1999 doesn't get remembered like Merkle's Boner. That two-hopper in the ninth inning of NLCS Game 4 was only thing that kept the Mets from being swept, and it was all Ozzie. So what should we call it? Guillen's Gaffe? Ozzie's Oops?


Placed RHP Brian Falkenborg on the 60-day DL (sprained ulnar collateral ligament). [3/23]

Optioned LHP Matt Riley to Rochester. [3/25]

Purchased the contract of RHP Tim Worrell. [3/27]

Placed RHP Scott Erickson on the 15-day DL (elbow); optioned 1B Calvin Pickering, Tall Guy Ryan Minor, CF Eugene Kingsale and RHPs Radhames Dykhoff, Gabe Molina and Jason Johnson to Rochester; reassigned C Tommy Davis and RHPs Rafael Pina and Javier De La Hoya to their minor-league camp. [3/28]

Scott Erickson is hurt, Jason Johnson loses his rotation spot and the organization decides to get bitchy as Matt Riley's quirks become less endearing. Once Boss Angelos discovers that his team is primed for an epic collapse, expect fireworks. The idea that Jose Mercedes and Calvin Maduro will be in the fourth and fifth slots of the rotation to open the season is going to encourage lots of verbiage over "expansion pitching," instead of more appropriate remarks about Orioles player development and bad taste in minor-league free agents.

There is a sunny side to all this: Maduro is one of the Orioles' original Aruba wunderkinder, so there is some justice that he's getting a shot at a job after being jerked around by the Phillies. But until this team realizes Jeff Conine is waiver bait and makes time for Calvin Pickering, and until they stop blathering about Ryan Minor as a prospect, they're setting themselves up for a breakdown every bit as dramatic as the late collapse in 1986 that heralded a new dark age. Only a suspension of Clan Angelos, like Steinbrenner's Howie Spira travail, would give somebody the chance to set things straight.


Signed manager Jimy Williams to a one-year contract extension through 2001; placed RHP Rod Beck on the 15-day disabled list (nerve irritation - neck); optioned RHP Chris Reitsma to Pawtucket. [3/28]

Placed RHP Jin Ho Cho on the 15-day DL (thoracic nerve irritation); optioned LHP Sang-Hoon Lee to Pawtucket. [3/29]

Claimed RHP Nerio Rodriguez off of waivers from the Mets. [3/31]

No really shocking news, except for what you don't see here. You know, the part where Dan Duquette tells Gary Gaetti that he'd be more useful to society if he gave it all up to be rendered into glue? Sadly, the Duke didn't make that choice when it needed to be made. Maybe John Valentin's steady decline has Duquette feeling needy at third base, but Gaetti's professional life is turning into a reprise of Graig Nettles's role as the third baseman who wouldn't die.

While some people really would like to see the Sox make some noise, is it fair to expect it of a team carrying ex-Cubs like Gaetti and Manny Alexander? I've heard far too many apologies for Ramon Martinez at this point, and I'm not buying into the idea that he's somehow going to be something special this year, even if he is healthy.


Traded RHP Rodney Myers to the Padres for CF Gary Matthews Jr.; optioned Matthews to Iowa; outrighted RHP Steve Rain to Iowa; assigned OF Chris Hatcher to their minor-league camp; released RHP Greg McMichael. [3/23]

Placed 3B Willie Greene on the 15-day DL, retroactive to 3/23 (lacerated hand); recalled 3B Cole Liniak from Iowa. [3/24]

Placed OF Glenallen Hill on the 15-day DL, retroactive to 3/20 (strained hamstring); placed RHPs Kerry Wood on the 15-day DL and Jeremi Gonzalez on the 60-day DL; recalled C Jose Molina from Iowa; optioned LHP Ray King to Iowa; purchased the contracts of OF Tarrik Brock and IF Jeff Huson from Iowa. [3/28]

The nightmare roster came to pass, as expected. Don Baylor picked bad regulars and worse bench players, with the Cubs talking about how well they're going to advance the runner. Too bad there aren't great OBP guys in the lineup, or four outs in an inning.

There is some silver lining. Little Sarge should push the immortal Tarrik Brock aside by May, assuming the Padres don't reverse the deal now that Myers has come up with a busted arm. Once Glenallen Hill and Willie Greene heal up, the Cubs will have two good hitters on the bench, which they need. But they've already been bitten in the butt by Baylor's inane decision to carry three left-handers in the pen, and while keeping Greg McMichael probably wasn't the solution, roster makeup has already cost the Cubs one game. Another 90 or so and nobody will notice, right?


Acquired SS Jose Olmedo from the Indians for future considerations. [3/27]

Optioned SS Mike Caruso and RHP Carlos Castillo to Charlotte; placed RHP Aaron Myette on the 15-day DL, retroactive to 3/25 (broken hand); assigned IF Liu Rodriguez to their minor-league camp. [3/28]

Optioned RHP Kevin Beirne and LHP Jesus Pena to Charlotte; waived RHP Carlos Castillo; assigned C Eric Christopherson to their minor-league camp. [3/29]

Placed C Brook Fordyce on the 15-day DL, retroactive to March 25; placed IF Jeff Liefer on the 15-day DL, retroactive to March 25; recalled CF McKay Christensen from Charlotte. [3/30]

There are a couple of potential surprises as far as who's making the roster as a result of these moves. Chances are that Kelly Wunsch, the sidearming left-hander and ex-Brewer first-round pick, is in, especially now that Pena's wildness has finally turned off Jerry Manuel. Chad Bradford has to beat out Tanyon Sturtze. Chances are Sturtze gets the job, because adding him to the 40-man roster cost the Sox Mario Valdez, who could/should/would have made the team as well as making the project to move Paul Konerko to third base a better idea. That's too bad, since I've been hoping against hope that the Sox would carry side-arming Bradford to complement Wunsch.

Elsewhere? The plan for Caruso is that he'll spend five days a week playing shortstop and two playing second base. If you're concerned for his future, you should be. Christensen's back on the roster to be the fifth outfielder now that Brian Simmons is out for the year.

The real surprise is that Jeff Abbott has made the team as the fourth outfielder, after begging to be traded all winter. He may get a good chunk of playing time at DH, or in left field if Carlos Lee plays DH. The no-nonsense move was the decision to cut loose Carlos Castillo, who was rightfully bitter about losing out on a rotation spot to Cal Eldred. The problem is that Eldred is arguably the only guy in camp Castillo could beat out. While he makes Bobby Munoz or Kent Bottenfield look svelte, chances are he's going to pop up as somebody's tateriffic fifth starter.


Optioned RHP Scott Winchester to Louisville. [3/23]

Assigned RHPs Osvaldo Fernandez and Bobby Munoz to Louisville. [3/26]

Assigned DH Brooks Kieschnick to their minor-league camp. [3/27]

Sold RHP Eddie Galliard to the Chunichi Dragons of the Japanese Leagues; optioned C Jason LaRue to Louisville and IF Travis (Gookie) Dawkins to Chattanooga (Double-A). [3/28]

Released RHP Mark Portugal; placed CB Deion Sanders on the 15-day DL (inflamed ankle); recalled RHP Rob Bell, LHP Hector Mercado and C Benito Santiago from Louisville. [3/29]

Outrighted CF Kimera Bartee to Louisville. [3/30]

I'm impressed, sort of. Sure, Jim Bowden never should have promised to make Mark Portugal the fifth starter. But the Reds weren't going to help themselves by using Portugal, especially with Ron Villone looking like he really needs to go back to giving the team quality long relief. I'm impressed by the decision to acknowledge they're a better team with Rob Bell in the rotation right now. He's young and his arm is still tender, but Jack McKeon was willing to be careful with Steve Parris, and with the Reds' deep pen and McKeon's willingness to use it, this is one of the better situations for a rookie starter.

I'm not overly bitter about Benito Santiago sneaking past Jason LaRue for the job of caddying for Eddie Taubensee. He still has value as a platoon partner, and he can still catch. LaRue didn't build on his great 1998 season at Triple-A in 1999, and could use the regular playing time. If something happens to Taubensee, LaRue can come up and split the job with Santiago; if something happens to Santiago, LaRue will come up with the benefit of having had regular playing time at Louisville. If Santiago sucks, Bowden can cut him, and LaRue will still have had the advantage of regular playing time.

The thing I don't get (and won't) is Bowden's bizarre Freon Deion fetish. Pine Time isn't going to be any better than the bad player he was before. Once healthy, he won't be more useful than Michael Tucker or Alex Ochoa. His only obvious talent will be as a media distraction from Ken Griffey Jr. That might be worth keeping him around on the DL until rosters expand in September.

The longshot of longshots is Hector Mercado making the team. I don't know if he's still tossing the splitter, but there aren't many left-handers who rely on it. I'm looking forward to checking him out.


Assigned LHP Al Newman to their minor-league camp. [3/23]

Placed RHP David Riske on the 15-day DL (bulging disc - lower back); optioned RHPs Jim Brower and Justin Speier and CF Dave Roberts to Buffalo; assigned RHP Jamie Brewington and C Matt Nokes to their minor-league camp. [3/25]

Assigned LHP Chris Haney to their minor-league camp. [3/26]

Traded RHP Steve Falteisek to the Marlins for SS Victor Rodriguez; traded SS Jose Olmeda to the White Sox for future considerations. [3/27]

Signed RHPs Clint Sodowsky and Joe Roa and LHP Brian Looney to minor-league contracts. [3/28]

Waived RHP Scott Sanders. [3/29]

Released CF Lance Johnson. [3/30]

The result of these moves really just bring two issues come to the fore: center field and left-handed relief. Since Kenny Lofton is healthy enough and Lance Johnson is bad, the only question is whether Charlie Manuel gave Jim Riggleman the private pleasure of putting the note to see the manager in Johnson's locker. Dislocated shoulder or not, I can't imagine Lofton throws worse than the healthy Master of the Looping Rainbow Toss. Jacob Cruz will undoubtedly get a bunch of playing time in center field in the first month or two, an opportunity he earned years ago.

The more troubling predicament is the left-handed relief situation. Neither Tom Martin nor Ricky Rincon have pitched well, and Haney was having trouble breaking 80 mph. There are all sorts of reasons to expect a trade with a team like the Reds, Twins or Cubs, who have southpaw relievers to spare.


Released RHP Billy Taylor. [3/23]

Announced that CF Chris Latham cleared waivers, and outrighted him to Colorado Springs; optioned LHP Rigo Beltran to Colorado Springs; released C Raul Casanova. [3/24]

Released IF David Howard; assigned LHP Ed Vosberg and OF Bubba Carpenter to their minor-league camp; optioned C Ben Petrick to Colorado Springs. [3/27]

Acquired C Jason Dewey and OF Norm Hutchins from the Angels in exchange for OF Edgard Clemente. [3/29]

Signed CF Brian Hunter; placed RHP Mike DeJean on the 15-day DL. [3/30]

It gets lost in the shuffle, but the Rox pitching has gotten awfully deep as a result of all of Dan O'Dowd's moves. Rigo Beltran is clearly useful, but there's no room for him on the roster. Even with Billy Taylor's release and the injuries to Jerry DiPoto and Mike DeJean, the Rox pen has David Lee, Skippy Belinda, Rich Croushore, Mike Myers, Manny Aybar, Jose Jimenez and Julian Tavarez in it. For a team short two veteran relievers, that isn't the worst situation in the world. Nevertheless, it isn't too unlikely that they'll swap one of Aybar or Jimenez to some team short of starting pitching for a better reliever.

The rest is sort of a mess. It's one thing to try an entirely new paradigm for winning in Coors Field (contact and speed, figuring the altitude will take care of the power), but a center field platoon of Tom Goodwin and Brian McRae strains the limits of credulity. If they both get considerable playing time, I could see them combining for 30 triples, and either of them could be the first guy to pop 20 since Lance Johnson had 21 for the Mets in 1996.

Making space on the 40-man roster explains a lot as far as moving Taylor, Chris Latham and Edgard Clemente, and losing Derrick Gibson on waivers. The Rox needed to make space for Scott Servais, and seem to have pulled it off. Picking up Dewey is a good move for an organization stocked with no-hit organizational soldiers like Mark Strittmatter. With Petrick at Colorado Springs and Dewey at New Haven, the Rox will get good catching at their top two levels. Hutchins is no prospect, but neither was Clemente, so nabbing some organizational depth at catcher in this exchange was a nice, if unexciting, bit of improvement.


Optioned RHP Masao Kida to Toledo; assigned IF Tilson Brito to minor-league camp; placed LHP Sean Runyan on the 15-day DL. [3/28]

Optioned IF Gabe Alvarez to Toledo; assigned IF Jose Macias to their minor-league camp. [3/29]

Optioned RHP Jeff Weaver to Toledo; assigned RHP Nelson Cruz and LHP Allen McDill to their minor-league camp. [3/30]

Jeff Weaver's "demotion" is only one to the fifth slot in the rotation, courtesy of having an option. He'll be back by the second week of April. There might be some mild surprise that last year's Japanese splash Masao Kida lost out to this year's project, Rule 5er Mark Johnson.

I'm disappointed that they demoted Tilson Brito, who could have been a useful bat off of the bench, since Deivi Cruz and Damion Easley don't exactly need a defensive replacement. But Shane Halter is being kept because he's willing to do emergency catching, and Phil Garner wants to try to get Robert Fick some at-bats. Compared to which utility infielder to keep around, playing Fick is easily the more important consideration.


Claimed OF Derrick Gibson off of waivers from the Rockies. [3/24]

Optioned RHP Hector Almonte, 2B Amaury Garcia and CF Julio Ramirez to Calgary; optioned 2B/SS Pablo Ozuna to Portland (Double-A); assigned UT Chris Clapinski, C Chris Tremie and RHP Jason Grilli to their minor-league camp; acquired RHP Steve Falteisek from the Indians for SS Victor Rodriguez. [3/27]

Optioned C Ramon Castro to Calgary; assigned OF Mark Smith to their minor-league camp. [3/30]

Sandy Martinez? What competent major league team would choose to play Sandy Martinez in any capacity? While Ramon Castro did have a bad camp, the idea that the Marlins left themselves with no alternative other than Sandy Martinez to pair up with Mike Redmond if Castro wasn't ready is simply mind-boggling. That they had Chris Tremie (Sandy Martinez Lite) in camp should be a hint.

Dave Dombrowski's taste in players to pick up really has to be called into question after a winter in which the Marlins have added Brant Brown, Danny Bautista and now Derrick Gibson. All of these players are about as marginally useful as fifth outfielders get. As a group, they're only going to encourage more guys in Calgary to issue Kevin Millar-style challenges like, "call me up, because those guys suck."


Assigned RHPs Kip Gross and Joe Slusarski, LHP Erik Plantenberg, 3B Chris Truby, 1B Mike Robertson, OF Marc Sagmoen and C Pedro Lopez to their minor-league camp. [3/25]

Assigned SS Julio Lugo, IF Tripp Cromer and LF Lance Berkman to their minor-league camp. [3/26]

Acquired LHP Yorkis Perez from the Phillies for LHP Trever Miller; placed RHP Scott Elarton on the 15-day DL, retroactive to 3/28 (stretched rotator cuff). [3/29]

Russ Johnson doesn't have an option left, so even though Julio Lugo earned a crack at Tim Bogar's job at shortstop, the Astros couldn't make a tough choice. Their roster space for the last spot or two on the bench is already constrained: they haven't sorted out if the last spot on the roster is going towards pinch-runner and outfield defensive sub Glenn Barker or towards keeping Mitch Meluskey around as a third catcher. In a world where Sandy Martinez is suddenly back and Tyler Houston is being asked to catch, Paul Bako wouldn't make it through waivers.

Getting quality playing time at shortstop seems more important than a defensive replacement on a team that already has good outfielders in Richard Hidalgo, Roger Cedeno, Moises Alou and Matt Mieske. With that group, getting Daryle Ward off the field late in the game shouldn't be a problem.

I frankly don't see the rationale to want Yorkis Perez over Trever Miller, so as far as reshuffles go, this one doesn't seem to make much sense for the Astros.


Optioned LHP Tim Byrdak and LF Dee Brown to Omaha; assigned RHP Mike MacDougal to their minor-league camp. [3/23]

Acquired 1B-OF David McCarty from the Athletics for cash. [3/24]

Released 1B Paul Sorrento. [3/25]

Released RHP Ken Ryan and LHP Billy Brewer; optioned RHP Brett Laxton and LHP Jamie Walker to Omaha; assigned RHP Doug Bochtler to their minor-league camp. [3/28]

Sold C Sal Fasano to the Athletics; released RHP Tyler Green. [3/30]

Let me get this straight: in their deals over the last two months, the A's effectively get Jeremy Giambi, Sal Fasano and two helpings of cash in exchange for Brett Laxton, David McCarty and some of that cash back? Is this the Royals, or the Kansas City A's?

The Royals might be trolling for a left-handed reliever, because by cutting both Billy Brewer and Tim Byrdak, they don't have one. But the general news for the pitching staff seems pretty good. Despite losing Blake Stein until May, Chad Durbin, Chris Fussell and Dan Reichert have all had good camps, and it doesn't look like much of the journeyman dross that got dragged into camp is going to make the team. Now if only Herk learned to have his secretary tell Billy Beane that Mr. Robinson is out for the day....


Signed 3B Adrian Beltre to a three-year contract; purchased the contracts of SS Kevin Elster and RHP Mike Fetters; optioned LHP Jeff Williams to Albuquerque; assigned C Adam Melhuse to their minor-league camp; designated 3B Kevin Orie and RHP Dan Naulty for assignment. [3/23]

Optioned SS Alex Cora and OF Tony Mota to Albuquerque. [3/24]

Purchased the contract of C Chad Kreuter from Albuquerque; placed RHP Kris Foster on the 60-day DL. [3/28]

Optioned RHP Eric Gagne and C Paul LoDuca to Albuquerque. [3/29]

Assigned IF Jeff Branson to their minor-league camp. [3/30]

Placed RHP Antonio Osuna on the 15-day DL (partially torn ligament - elbow); outrighted SS Juan Castro to Albuquerque. [3/31]

Fox executives announced the signing of Primordial Slime. "We felt that Slime brought a lot of needed experience that might help fine young men like Mike Fetters, Kevin Elster and Chad Kreuter adjust to major-league life. Plus, the La Brea Tar Pits were willing to let Slime sign on as part of a work-release program. There are all sorts of synergies here. Slime has his own sitcom, and the writers from The Simpsons are already working him into a few plot lines. He even has a great shot at beating out John Goodman and Luke Perry for the title role in the new Joe Eszterhas screenplay on the life of Abe Lincoln."


Signed C Raul Casanova to a minor-league contract; optioned RHP Jeff D'Amico to Indianapolis. [3/24]

Optioned SSs Santiago Perez and Lou Collier to Indianapolis; re-assigned RHPs Mike Busby, Hector Ramirez, Eric Ludwick and Bob Scanlan, LHP Ricardo Jordan, 3B Jose Fernandez and OF Damon Hollins to Indianapolis. [3/28]

Claimed RHP Jason Boyd off of waivers from the Pirates; released Cs Bobby Hughes and Brian Banks and 1B Antone Williamson. [3/29]

There's only one bit of good news, indirectly reflected here: Ronnie Belliard will be able to play Opening Day. Everything else is bad news. Going with a catching tandem of Tyler Houston and Henry Blanco is a clear case of trying to out-Girardi the Girardis. "After all, somebody has to have the worst catching situation in the majors, so why not us?" Organizationally, the catching is so weak they're taking a spin with one of the original catcher prospect flameouts of the 90s, ex-Padre and ex-Tiger superstar-to-be Raul Casanova.

While the temporary answer for who the fourth and fifth starters are is currently Jason Bere and Horacio Estrada, neither of them may make it to May 1. The really noxious idea? That this team might somehow end up with both Sean Berry and Charlie Hayes on the roster. While the miseries of the Bando Era were bad, the Brewers seem determined to learn by example, and in this case, some of the worst ones.


Optioned RHPs Scott Randall and Jason Ryan to Salt Lake; assigned LHP Todd Rizzo to their minor-league camp. [3/23]

Optioned OF Brian Buchanan and C Javier Valentin to Salt Lake. [3/24]

Released RHP Bobby Ayala; optioned OF Chad Allen to Salt Lake; assigned OF Robin Jennings and C Jeff Smith to minor-league camp. [3/27]

Optioned RHP Mike Lincoln to Salt Lake; placed LHP J.C. Romero on the 15-day DL. [3/28]

The good news is old: they've sacked Doug Mientkiewicz, Javier Valentin and Chad Allen, and replaced them with David Ortiz, Matt LeCroy and...Butch Huskey? Torii Hunter? Midre Cummings? While they've clearly upgraded the team at first base and catcher, lordy, those aren't good solutions for left field. The better news is that there's clearly no commitment to Allen, which should only make it easier for Mike Restovich to scale the ladder and take the job by 2001. Other roster fun is that Jason Maxwell looks like he's made it, and he's potentially an outstanding platoon mate for Todd Walker.

Four left-handers in the pen? Four? Eddie Guardado is as good a situational lefty as there is, and Travis Miller a genuinely good one to boot. Rule 5er Johan Santana pitched well enough to stick, and Mark Redman has always had my sympathy during too many years at Salt Lake, so it's nice to see him make the team as a middle reliever.

But think about what that means for right-handed relief: Bob Wells and Hector Carrasco. Is that really what you want to count on? This is the Twins, and expectations are low, so they can afford to keep talent with an eye to the future rather than try to put their tactically-best pen together, but it's still an odd situation, one that could get stranger once Romero is healthy.


Placed RHP Mike Thurman on the 15-day DL. [3/23]

Optioned CF Milton Bradley and OF/1B Fernando Seguignol to Ottawa; assigned RHP Shayne Bennett to their minor-league camp. [3/27]

Released OF Manny Martinez. [3/29]

Two things seem clear: Peter Bergeron has won the starting job in center, which hopefully end the silly game of "which white center fielder does this player most closely resemble?" The other thing is that since Thurman wasn't going to heal, the fifth spot in the rotation is going to go to Jeremy Powell, behind a front four of Dustin Hermanson, Hideki Irabu, Javier Vazquez and Carl Pavano. Miguel Batista will resume his garbage/utility role in the pen, backing up Ugueth Urbina, the two left-handers (Steve Kline and David Wainhouse, until Graeme Lloyd gets healthy), Scott Strickland and Anthony Telford. That's one of the best top-to-bottom staffs around, at a time when all sorts of people seem to be sneaking onto rosters, and despite an injury and the demotion of Guillermo Mota.


Claimed RHP Nerio Rodriguez from the Toronto Blue Jays, only to lose him three days later on waivers to the Red Sox. [3/28]


Announced the retirement of HoF OF Tim Raines; traded SS Juan Melo to the Giants for SS Wilson Delgado; optioned SS/3B Alfonso Soriano to Columbus. [3/23]

Signed IF Carlos Garcia to a minor-league contract. [3/24]

Released IF Rafael Bournigal; assigned OF Ryan Thompson to their minor-league camp. [3/26]

Optioned LHP Eddie Yarnall to Columbus; released C Tom Pagnozzi, who retired. [3/28]

Assigned C Julio Mosquera to their minor-league camp. [3/29]

Signed CF Lance Johnson to a minor-leage camp. [3/31]

There is something sort of fun in the Yankees' decision to cut past people like Rafael Bournigal and keep Wilson Delgado around as their utility man, but most of these cuts reflect a lack of organizational depth. If Bernie Williams gets hit by a bus, who plays center field? Lance Johnson? Ryan Thompson? If Derek Jeter gets kidnapped by Whitney Houston cultists, who plays short? Delgado? Alfonso Soriano? Ugh.

The Yankees have reason to feel good about their pitching depth, to the point that they can afford to send Ed Yarnall back, so that they can kep Todd Erdos, because Yarnall hadn't earned the fifth spot ahead of Ramiro Mendoza. But the upper-level depth in the organization is too shallow for comfort at several positions.

Others have already said their goodbyes to Tim Raines on the site, and I said mine in the book. I'll miss him, I'll stump for him, and here's hoping he has a happy, healthy and long life ahead of him.


Assigned LHP Terry Burrows, RHP Jon Ratliff and C Cody McKay to their minor-league camp. [3/28]

Optioned C Danny Ardoin to Sacramento; assigned LHPs Doug Johns and Mark Mulder to minor-league camp; acquired C Sal Fasano from the Royals for cash. [3/30]

What is it they say about the criminal mind? About how it's dumb, because it'll lead to decisions like trying to rob the same convenience store a couple of times in a week, each time without a mask? What if the guy running the mini-mart is a samaritan who feels good for having his store knocked over because he's helping someone less fortunate than himself? No, it doesn't make much sense to me either, because I seem to recall that working in a mini-mart is one of the levels of Hell, but there's no explaining some people.

Anyway, A.J. Hinch has to feel pretty unlucky, since Sal Fasano should have his job within 48 hours. A great catch-and-throw guy with good power, Fasano is exactly what the A's needed from a caddy for Ramon Hernandez.

On other fronts, the A's are going with only one left-handed reliever, Mike Magnante, and Mark Mulder lost the fifth starting slot to Ron Mahay. It'll be interesting to see what happens in a month or two, since chances are that one of Mulder or Barry Zito will be ready to push into the rotation by then. Will Gil Heredia have broken down? Will Mahay go to the pen? Having pitching depth hasn't been something the A's have gotten to enjoy much in the last decade or so, so this will be an interesting predicament once it comes up in a few months.


Assigned 1B/LF Pat Burrell to their minor-league camp. [3/25]

Acquired 2B Mickey Morandini from the Expos for cash; assigned SS Felix Martinez, IF David Doster, LHP Bryan Ward and RHP Steve Schrenk to their minor-league camp; purchased the contract of LHP Yorkis Perez. [3/28]

Traded LHP Yorkis Perez to the Astros for LHP Trever Miller; assigned LHP Bryan Ward to their minor-league camp. [3/29]

Placed RHP Carlos Reyes on the 15-day DL; recalled RHP Steve Schrenk from their minor-league camp; assigned 1B Chris Pritchett to their minor-league camp. [3/30]

There's just something broken in somebody's head in this organization. While the Phillies do get to snicker at the Cubs' expense by having both Doug Glanville and Mickey Morandini on the team only two years after trading one for the other, portraying the pickup of Morandini as an improvement is just silly. He spent last year struggling to outhit Marlon Anderson, and most projections say that he'll have a hard time doing it this year as well.

This isn't like picking up an old Joe Morgan, in the hope that he can give you some sock. Morandini was an adequate player at his best, and now he isn't even that. There might be a slight improvement on defense, but not enough to help overcome this team's several weaknesses. Until the organization puts Pat Burrell in front of either Ron Gant or Rico Brogna, they're going to struggle to hold onto third place in the NL East.


Released RHP Mark Leiter. [3/23]

Released IF Dale Sveum; assigned CF Emil Brown, UT Jason Wood, C Tim Laker, RHPs Jose Parra, Josias Manzanillo and Jason Boyd to their minor-league camp. [3/26]

Released LHP Pete Schourek; optioned RHP Mike Garcia to Nashville; assigned 1B Ivan Cruz and C Randy Knorr to their minor-league camp. [3/29]

Optioned SS Abraham Nunez and LHP Jeff Wallace to Nashville. [3/30]

Cutting loose Schourek to keep Jimmy Anderson as the fifth starter isn't a choice I'd like to have to make. Considering that Todd Ritchie seems to have turned back into a toadstool, the rotation is starting to look exceptionally shallow for a team that some people think will contend.

There are several open-ended injury situations, with the health of both Jason Christiansen and Chris Peters in question. The right-handed relief is no better. It would be nice to see Jose Silva's snakebitten career finally get on track, but they're also counting on Marc Wilkins and Mike Williams. There's a good amount of talent here, considering they think they can afford to demote both Garcia and Wallace. But if they stick too long with some of last year's surprises, they'll be out of the race quickly. Keeping this staff in working order may be the biggest challenge for Gene Lamont and Pete Vuckovich yet.


Acquired CF Jim Edmonds from the Angels for RHP Kent Bottenfield and 2B Adam Kennedy. [3/23]

Assigned C Rick Wilkins to their minor-league camp. [3/29]

Released OF Brian McRae. [3/30]

Hats off to Walt Jocketty for making a great deal to fill an obvious need. Sure, between Ray Lankford and Jim Edmonds and Eric Davis, you have about the equivalent of two regular outfielders, but the Cardinals desperately need this kind of depth to avoid a repeat of what happened last year. Kent Bottenfield was never going to be any more valuable than he is now, and Garrett Stephenson is an excellent example of someone who could easily give you 150 quality innings or so as a fourth or fifth starter just as Bottenfield was last spring.

Considering they still have Mark Thompson handy, and that both Alan Benes and Matt Morris could be available by June, they've got more pitching depth than last year as well. They could use a better backup catcher than Mike Matheny, which is why the Carlos Hernandez rumors aren't going away, but Jocketty is finally putting together the kind of depth that this team needed last year. They're well-positioned to push for the Central title and/or the wild card.


Acquired RHP Rodney Myers from the Cubs for CF Gary Matthews Jr. [3/23]

Optioned RHPs Buddy Carlyle, Stan Spencer and Matt Whiteside and 2B Ralph Milliard to Las Vegas. [3/27]

Placed LHP Randy Myers on the 15-day DL and RHP Carlton Loewer on the 60-day DL. [3/28]

Optioned C Ben Davis to Las Vegas. [3/29]

Optioned OF Mike Darr and 2B/OF David Newhan to Las Vegas. [3/30]

No sooner do they pick up another pitcher named Myers than the Pads discover he's as broken down as the first one. It might be worth considering on the list of things for them to avoid in the future.

It's unfortunate for Davis that Kevin Towers couldn't find the right deal for Carlos Hernandez. If Towers pulls it off and gets a prospect of value, it will have justified the decision to give Hernandez the multi-year contract he otherwise hardly deserved. Davis will just have to take out his frustrations in Vegas.

Carlyle nearly made the team, and may yet get to come back if the other rumor (Sterling Hitchcock to anybody) comes true. Meanwhile, the rotation will be Hitchcock, Woody Williams, Matt Clement, Brian Meadows for a month or two and Brian Boehringer. Between Meadows's combustibility and Boehringer's wonky shoulder, there's a pretty good chance that by July the only survivors will be Clement and Williams.


Traded SS Wilson Delgado to the Yankees for SS Juan Melo. [3/23]

Optioned RHP Miguel del Toro to Fresno. [3/26]

Optioned RHP Ryan Jensen to Fresno; assigned SS Juan Melo to their minor-league camp. [3/28]

Designated 2B Jay Canizaro for assignment. [3/29]

No real shockers, although the interesting news is that del Toro is going to work out as a starter at Fresno. Given the obvious health concerns surrounding Russ Ortiz, Livan Hernandez and Shawn Estes, and since Mark Gardner is going to be himself, that's a reasonable precaution, one forced by the multiple trades Brian Sabean has made that have emptied the organization's upper levels of pitching prospects. Even then, don't think for a moment that they miss Chris Brock.


Outrighted RHP Brian Fuentes and LF Shane Monahan to Tacoma. [3/24]

Assigned 2B Willie Bloomquist and SS Antonio Perez to their minor-league camp. [3/26]

Released CF Brian Hunter. [3/27]

Assigned C Julio Machado to their minor-league camp. [3/28]

Claimed CF Anthony Sanders off of waivers from the Blue Jays. [3/31]

The same organization that gave you multi-million cost overruns for concrete now kisses six hundred thousand smackers goodbye for making the mistake of offering Brian Hunter salary arbitration. Hunter's value should have been determined by the waiver wire, not by an arbitrator, and Pat Gillick deserves the credit for blowing this decision. Even the "savings" they get for cutting him now hardly makes up for the fact that it should have been done in October.


Optioned CF Randy Winn to Durham; assigned DH Dave Hollins to their minor-league camp; released C Mike Figga and RHPs John Burkett and Chad Ogea; signed IF Rafael Bournigal to a minor-league contract. [3/29]

Sent Rule 5 pick RHP Chris Reitsma back to the Red Sox. [3/28]

Released LHP Norm Charlton. [3/31]

Not a bad group of moves for the D-Rays. The one I like is the decision to bring in Rafael Bournigal to play short at Durham, only to come up if/when Kevin Stocker gets hurt (again). That means they'll be keeping Bobby Smith and Tony Graffanino as their utilitymen. I tend to lean towards keeping better hitters on the bench, and since the D-Rays will need to pinch-hit for Stocker, their catchers and Miguel Cairo as often as possible, carrying a pair of backup infielders who can hit more than Bournigal seems like one of the better ideas the Rays have had since their inception.

Charlton will be signed. It isn't whether or not he still has anything left, or whether or not he'll be adequate. He's left-handed, and as you've probably noticed, several teams could use someone like that. Whichever ones have space to play with on their 40-man rosters, or who aren't constrained by player options, will win the booby prize.


Assigned RHPs Brian Sikorski and Chuck Smith to Oklahoma. [3/26]

Optioned 3B Mike Lamb to Oklahoma. [3/29]

Tom Evans wins the third base job, and with Frank Catalanotto getting some time there as well, the Rangers might have a platoon in place that could stir up memories of the great Blue Jays platoon of Rance Mulliniks and Garth Iorg. The fun thing about the Rangers' bench and roster right now is that Luis Alicea could disappear and they could replace him with a potent Catalanotto/Scott Sheldon platoon. I'm beating a dead horse, but this is a fun and flexible roster. Whether or not Johnny Oates will put it to work is an open question. With either the Rangers or the Orioles, he hasn't been inclined to use his bench much. It will be interesting to see if he breaks that pattern this year.


Signed OF Marty Cordova to a one-year contract; assigned OF Jacob Brumfield to their minor-league camp. [3/27]

Between picking up Brad Fullmer for David Segui and Marty Cordova for cash, I'm impressed that Gord Ash is giving Jim Fregosi enough offensive weapons to surprise people this year. The Jays' chances are still heavily dependent on whether or not the young rotation comes around, but if it stays healthy while the Yankees or the Red Sox have to worry about their lack of depth, there's a potential for a serious push in the AL East.

Christina Kahrl is an author of Baseball Prospectus. 
Click here to see Christina's other articles. You can contact Christina by clicking here

Related Content:  Wilson Delgado,  Matt Williams,  Jose Fernandez,  Will Myers,  Minor Leagues,  Carlos Martinez,  Charlie Tilson,  Minor League Baseball,  A's,  Luke Scott,  Chris Perez,  Out Of My League,  The Platoon Advantage,  Left Field,  Kevin Brown,  Chris Carpenter,  Fernando Martinez,  Brett Myers,  Back,  Manuel Pina,  Mike Minor,  Randall Delgado,  Chad Durbin,  David Robertson,  Rookie Of The Year,  Depth,  Tim Byrdak,  Juan Perez,  Starting Rotation,  C.j. Wilson,  The Who,  Brian Wilson,  Minor League Player Of The Year,  Bench,  Ramon Santiago,  Shawn Camp,  Chris Davis,  Dan Johnson,  What You Need To Know,  Chris Nelson,  Minor League Opening Day,  Brad Miller,  Hector Santiago,  A.J. Hinch,  Mike Rizzo,  David Ortiz,  Time,  Jamie Garcia,  Chris Johnson,  Good Plays,  Jason Adam,  Rotation,  David Segui,  Brian Roberts,  Jeff Conine,  Russ Miller,  Jose Jimenez,  Jason Jennings,  Mike Myers,  Chad Bradford,  Jason Grilli,  Dan Brooks,  Sal Fasano,  Jason LaRue,  Rafael Soriano,  Bobby Bonilla,  Jose Hernandez,  Brian Fuentes,  Jim Edmonds,  Jeff Kent,  Benito Santiago,  Kevin Cash,  Julio Rodriguez,  Ramon Castro,  David Bell,  T.J. Tucker,  Jose Macias,  Jim Brower,  Robert Johnson,  Mini-camp,  Jeff Nelson,  David Wells,  Rosters,  Jeff Clement,  David Cooper,  Ryan Brett,  Year Of The Injury,  Marlins Trade For Carlos Lee,  Fourth Of July,  Japanese League,  A-rod,  Off-day,  The Call-up,  Jose Lopez,  Left-handers,  Jim Riggleman,  Jim Powell,  News,  Base 3,  Brett Anderson,  Roster,  Team,  Kevin Long,  Catching,  Manager Of The Year,  Steve Johnson

0 comments have been left for this article.

No Previous Article
<< Previous Column
Transaction Analysis: ... (03/24)
Next Column >>
Transaction Analysis: ... (04/17)
No Next Article

Playoff Prospectus: Come Undone
BP En Espanol: Previa de la NLCS: Cubs vs. D...
Playoff Prospectus: How Did This Team Get Ma...
Playoff Prospectus: Too Slow, Too Late
Premium Article Playoff Prospectus: PECOTA Odds and ALCS Gam...
Premium Article Playoff Prospectus: PECOTA Odds and NLCS Gam...
Playoff Prospectus: NLCS Preview: Cubs vs. D...

The Week in Quotes: March 27-April 3
The Daily Prospectus: Life's Not Fair

2000-04-21 - Transaction Analysis: April 18-19, 2000
2000-04-19 - Transaction Analysis: April 12-17
2000-04-17 - Transaction Analysis: March 23-31, 2000
2000-04-03 - Transaction Analysis: March 23-31, 2000
2000-03-29 - AL Central Notebook
2000-03-24 - Transaction Analysis: March 14-22, 2000
2000-03-15 - Transaction Analysis: March 7-13

2000-04-21 - Transaction Analysis: April 18-19, 2000
2000-04-19 - Transaction Analysis: April 12-17
2000-04-17 - Transaction Analysis: March 23-31, 2000
2000-04-03 - Transaction Analysis: March 23-31, 2000
2000-03-24 - Transaction Analysis: March 14-22, 2000
2000-03-15 - Transaction Analysis: March 7-13
2000-03-08 - Transaction Analysis: February 25-March 6, 2...