Baseball Prospectus

MLB Statistics

Statistics for All Levels

Statistics For All Levels

Plate Discipline

Comparable Players (Similarity Index )

BP Annual Player Comments

Year		Comment
2012		At this point, Varitek's greatest strength is his ability to handle a pitching staff. He split playing time with Jarrod Saltalamacchia about 60/40 this year, but with far less success overall, as he was nearly an automatic out against right-handed pitchers. He also threw out just 14 percent of runners, allowing 73 of 88 baserunners to steal–and Varitek wasn't the one catching Tim Wakefield's slow floater, either. It has been a good run for Varitek, a career .256/.341/.435 catcher with a highly-regarded defensive past despite some of the present problems, but it might be the end for this 40-year-old.
2011		Boston's captain alternated between awful and awesome, striking out 35 times in 123 plate appearances with a sub-.300 OBP while also knocking seven balls over the fence. Like every other Sox starting catcher, Varitek got hurt and didn't return until Victor Martinez was already back and the Sox were all but mathematically eliminated. Considering Varitek has hit .187/.259/.354 since Boston acquired Martinez and has thrown out fewer than 19 percent of potential base thieves in the past two years, don't expect him to have much impact outside of a mentoring or clubhouse role.
2010		Varitek has hit an aggregate .222/.316/.382 in three of the last four seasons. Last year he added an inability to catch opposing basestealers, throwing out just 13 percent of them (against a league average of 25 percent). It was no surprise that the Sox declined his $5 million club option, or that he picked up his $3 million player option. As a result, he’ll be the backup catcher this season, most likely serving as Josh Beckett's caddy and catching games against the odd lefty starter, as his last remaining positive at the plate seems to be some power from the right side.
2009		The slow-swinged shadow of his former self hit .201/.293/.323 against right-handers, suggesting that he should either stick to batting right-handed or take up the short end of a catching platoon, perhaps the perfect way to transition into the role of player-coach or player-manager. Agent Scott Boras has stated that neither of those options is in Varitek's plans, though, as he intends to catch full-time for somebody. Taken with Boras' initial demand that Varitek reel in a contract like Jorge Posada's current four-year, $52.4 million deal, these considerations have ensured that for Tek the news wire is filled with the sounds of crickets rather than ongoing negotiations.
2008		The four-year extension he received after 2004 has worked out reasonably well, with Varitek having had two good years and one poor one thus far. Having a better backup to take 15 to 20 more starts from him would help, as he's worn down in his last two full seasons. The mileage is definitely taking a toll on his power, which may not bounce back without more time off.
2007		Awash in their championship afterglow, the Sox signed Varitek to a four-year, $40-million contract knowing they`d be paying for his decline; they just didn`t expect it to start in Year Two of the deal. Varitek never got on track in 2006. His .243/.331/.411 line through July 31 would have been his worst since 2002, but a torn medial meniscus gave `worst` a whole new meaning. In the captain`s absence, the team went 10-23, plunging out of the playoff picture with the grace of a Boomer Wells cannonball. Upon returning, Varitek struck out an alarming 29 times in 61 AB, suggesting he still wasn`t right. He`ll have the winter to recuperate, but the Sox must reckon with owning a 35-year-old catcher whose body is no longer under warranty.
2006		After signing a seemingly ill-considered four-year, $40 million dollar contract, Varitek went out and easily justified the first year of the deal. Of course, it was never the first year, nor the second, that was going to be the problem; it`s still probable that the Sox felt that the only way to secure two good years of Varitek was to also pay for the two bad ones that were likely to come after. Now sporting an NHL-style "C" on his uniform, Jason is four months younger than Ivan Rodriguez and eight months younger than Jorge Posada, but he`s played hundreds fewer major league games than both, thanks in large part to Scott Boras` tough negotiating tactics. Those tactics may have cost Varitek money at the time, but could add some length to his career.
2005		Following up his impressive 2003 campaign with an equally productive 2004, Varitek has established himself as one of the best offensive catchers in the game. He established a new career high in OBP, continued to hit for power, and hasn't yet shown the inevitable wear and tear common among backstops. Still, the history of catchers entering their mid-30s is littered with disappointments. The Sox gave him $40 million through age 36, a political signing if ever there was one.
2004		Varitek's great season was not a fluke-he was having a similar one in 2001 until he broke his elbow, and it took him a year and a half to fully recover. He and his hefty 2001-era contract (three years/$14.9 million) could have been had cheaply all last winter, but the Red Sox got their money's worth out of their #9 hitter. With his contract expiring at the end of 2004, and with the popular backstop approaching his mid-30s, a lot of people are already handing Shoppach the 2005 catcher's job.
2003		Like Nixon, Varitek achieved new heights in 2001. Unfortunately, Varitek also shared in the disappointment of 2002, as he hit .209 with only 2 HR in August and September. Varitek has a strong defensive reputation, but he’s already 30, and at this point is unlikely to ever develop into an offensive star. However, he is set to earn $4.7 million in 2003 and $6.7 million in 2004. If Kelly Shoppach continues to progress in the minors, the Red Sox should consider shopping Varitek at the trading deadline, before the shine comes entirely off.
2002		Varitek’s broken elbow was a cruel addition to the injury brigade, and one that hurt about as much as Garciaparra’s injury did. Varitek was off to a great start, one that had him in the top tier of AL catchers, when he went down, and despite the plethora of free catching talent available in 2001, the Sox ended up giving most of the playing time to Scott Hatteberg, who couldn’t hit the windshield if the bus stopped short. Varitek is expected to be 100 percent by spring training, and both he and the Sox need a big season from him.
2001		Although Jason Varitek’s season appears to be a disappointment, rumors abound that he was playing with a sore right hand and wrist that affected his swing and robbed him of most of his power. If he is healed by April, he's in line for a breakthrough year at the plate and a big raise after the season.
2000		Varitek took advantage of Hatteberg's injury to become the second-best offensive catcher in the AL. He hit equally well from both sides of the plate last year and is good defensively--his high passed-ball total comes from catching Tim Wakefield's knuckler. The deal that brought Varitek and Derek Lowe to Boston for Heathcliff Slocumb is starting to look like Jeff Bagwell for Larry Andersen in reverse.
1999		Now that he's spent a year in the majors, he's no longer known as the former Scott Boras holdout. Went to Lake Brantley High School in Florida, my alma mater.
1998		Who’s laughing now? The Twins, probably. The Phillies should keep mentioning Varitek’s name in the J.D. Drew negotiations. The Hatteberg/Leyritz platoon will probably be more productive than Varitek in 1998. If he has a good season, he might be worth taking a shot on in 1999 for his Age 27 year.
1997		The next time a team drafts a player represented by Scott Boras and the negotiations get tough, they should put the kid in touch with Varitek. Boras’ hard-line tactics turned away the Twins, who drafted him as a junior, and when the Mariners drafted him the following year, he insisted on marquee money. As a senior Varitek had no leverage, and held out until the following March. He eventually got $650,000, about average money for a late first-round pick, but lost about two years of development. His second season with a wood bat was discouragingly like his first, not what anyone expected from one of the greatest catchers in collegiate history. He’ll probably take a step forward this year, but he’s 25, and his star potential is almost gone.
1996		Introduced himself to the Mariners with a vicious contract dispute. Appears to be a very bright young man, and he's certainly impressive with the glove. I expect he'll hit better than indicated above, after the dreaded "Wooden Bat Adjustment." The Mariners may have more good prospects up the middle than any team in recent memory. Will have to be at least 30 before he's in Lou Piniella's comfort zone, no doubt.

BP Articles

BP Chats

BP Roundtables

Advanced Catching Metrics

PITCHf/x Hitter Profile

A Collaboration between BrooksBaseball.net and Baseball Prospectus - Pitch classifications provided by Pitch Info LLC